Automobile airbags are more dangerous than safe during accidents
the verdict
INSUFFICIENT LEANING
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
0 sources for · 2 against
Two peer-reviewed studies discuss injuries and symptoms associated with automobile airbag use without supporting the claim that they are more dangerous than safe.
Automobile Airbag Impulse Noise: Otologic Symptoms in Six Patients | CiNii Research 検索 タイトル 人物/団体名 著者ID/研究者番号 所属機関 ISSN DOI 期間 〜 本文リンク 本文リンクあり データソース JaLC IRDB Crossref DataCite NDLサーチ NDLデジコレ（旧NII-ELS） RUDA JDCat NINJAL CiNii Articles CiNii Books NACSIS-CAT/ILL DBpedia KAKEN e-Rad Integbio PubMed LSDB Archive 極地研ADS 極地研学術DB OpenAIRE 公共データカタログ すべて 研究データ 論文 本 博士論文 プロジェクト 人物 > 人物検索機能について 詳細検索 閉じる CiNii Researchナレッジグラフ検索機能（試行版）をCiNii Labsにて公開しました 「研究データ」「根拠データ」の収録について CiNii Books機能統合対応の追加実施をいたしました Automobile Airbag Impulse Noise: Otologic Symptoms in Six Patients DOI Web Site Web Site Web Site 被引用文献4件 James E.
Saunders Hearing and Balance Center/Saint Anthony Hospital Oklahoma City Oklahoma William H. Slattery House Ear Clinic and House Ear Institute Los Angeles California William M. Luxford House Ear Clinic and House Ear Institute Los Angeles California 書誌事項 公開日 1998-02 権利情報 http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/termsAndConditions#vor DOI 10.1016/s0194-5998(98)80021-1 公開者 Wiley この論文をさがす CiNii Books 説明 <jats:p>Automobile airbag safety systems have successfully reduced the number of occupant injuries from motor vehicle accidents. Unfortunately, airbags are also associated with some inherent risk, including a high‐amplitude, short‐duration noise from airbag deployment.
A review of the available research in the automobile industry indicates that the peak amplitude of this noise may exceed 170 dB sound pressure level. Despite the increasingly wide application of airbags in automobiles, there have been no previous reports of airbag‐related otologic injuries. We have encountered six patients with otologic symptoms that appear to be related to airbag impulse noise. Five of these patients have documented hearing loss, one patient reported persistent tinnitus, and two patients have significant dysequilibrium. Although permanent hearing loss from airbag noise appears to be rare, temporary threshold shifts are probably much more common.
It is important, therefore, that the clinician be aware of the noise associated with airbag inflation and the possibility of acoustic trauma from these safety devices.</jats:p> 収録刊行物 Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery 118 (2), 228-234, 1998-02 Wiley 被引用文献 (4) *注記 読み込み中...
Summary The wide use of automobile airbags has undoubtedly reduced the mortality and the incidence of serious injuries from motor vehicle accidents. However, automobile airbags appear to be associated with a variety of injuries including fatal injuries, ocular injuries, upper limb and chest injuries. Further improvements in airbag design together with education of the general public in their use should help reduce airbag-related injuries.
Patterns of injury associated with automobile airbag use | CiNii Research 検索 タイトル 人物/団体名 著者ID/研究者番号 所属機関 ISSN DOI 期間 〜 本文リンク 本文リンクあり データソース JaLC IRDB Crossref DataCite NDLサーチ NDLデジコレ（旧NII-ELS） RUDA JDCat NINJAL CiNii Articles CiNii Books NACSIS-CAT/ILL DBpedia KAKEN e-Rad Integbio PubMed LSDB Archive 極地研ADS 極地研学術DB OpenAIRE 公共データカタログ すべて 研究データ 論文 本 博士論文 プロジェクト 人物 > 人物検索機能について 詳細検索 閉じる CiNii Researchナレッジグラフ検索機能（試行版）をCiNii Labsにて公開しました 「研究データ」「根拠データ」の収録について CiNii Books機能統合対応の追加実施をいたしました Patterns of injury associated with automobile airbag use DOI PDF 被引用文献2件 A A Mohamed Accident and Emergency Department, Whittington Hospital , Highgate Hill, London N19 5NF, UK A Banerjee Accident and Emergency Department, Whittington Hospital , Highgate Hill, London N19 5NF, UK 書誌事項 公開日 1998-08-01 権利情報 https://academic.oup.com/pages/standard-publication-reuse-rights DOI 10.1136/pgmj.74.874.455 公開者 Oxford University Press (OUP) この論文をさがす CiNii Books 説明 <jats:title>Summary</jats:title> <jats:p>The wide use of automobile airbags has undoubtedly reduced the mortality and the incidence of serious injuries from motor vehicle accidents.
However, automobile airbags appear to be associated with a variety of injuries including fatal injuries, ocular injuries, upper limb and chest injuries. Further improvements in airbag design together with education of the general public in their use should help reduce airbag-related injuries.</jats:p> 収録刊行物 Postgraduate Medical Journal Postgraduate Medical Journal 74 (874), 455-458, 1998-08-01 Oxford University Press (OUP) 被引用文献 (2) *注記 読み込み中...
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.