trustme.bro/r/…
✓ checked
trust me, bro:
here is the receipt.
the claim
Tin forms stable tin(II) compounds due to the inert pair effect
the verdict
INSUFFICIENT LEANING
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
3 sources for · 0 against
AS REPORTEDno primary record reached; this is what the reporting says

Retrieved sources partially mention tin's divalent state and discuss factors like d-block contraction or lesser relativistic effects for row 5 elements, but do not fully substantiate that tin forms stable tin(II) compounds strictly due to the inert pair effect in the manner ascribed to heavier congeners.

Evidence for · 3
cited by 0
contraction of the 6s orbital compared to the 6p orbital and rendering it relatively unreactive in ionic compounds. The inert pair effect is less pronounced Lead ( ) is a chemical element with the symbol Pb (from the Latin plumbum) and atomic number 82. It is a heavy metal, denser than most common materials. Lead is soft, malleable, and has a relatively low melting point. When freshly cut or melted, it appears shiny silvery with a bluish tint, but tarnishes to dull gray on exposure to air. Lead has the highest atomic number of any stable element, and Lead exhibits two principal oxidation states: +4 and +2. While the tetravalent state is characteristic of the carbon group, the divalent state is rare for carbon and silicon, less common for germanium, significant but not dominant for tin, and the most prevalent for lead. This predominance is linked to relativistic effects—specifically the inert pair effect—which occurs when there is a large electronegativity difference between lead and anions such as oxide, halide, or nitride. In such cases, lead develops a pronounced partial positive charge, causing a stronger contraction of the 6s orbital compared to the 6p orbital and rendering it relatively unreactive in ionic compounds. The inert pair effect is less pronounced in compounds where lead forms covalent bonds with elements of similar electronegativity, such as carbon in organolead compounds. In these, the 6s and 6p orbitals remain comparable in size, and sp3 hybridization remains energetically favorable, making lead predominantly tetravalent in such cases. The electronegativity values further reflect this behavior: lead(II) has a value of 1.87, and lead(IV) has 2.33. This represents a reversal in the general trend of increasing stability of the +4 oxidation state down the carbon group; by comparison, tin has electronegativities of 1.80 (+2 state) and 1.96 (+4 state). Lead… Lead exhibits two principal oxidation states: +4 and +2. While the tetravalent state is characteristic of the carbon group, the divalent state is rare for carbon and silicon, less common for germanium, significant but not dominant for tin, and the most prevalent for lead. This predominance is linked to relativistic effects—specifically the inert pair effect—which occurs when there is a large electronegativity difference between lead and anions such as oxide, halide, or nitride. In such cases, lead develops a pronounced partial positive charge, causing a stronger contraction of the 6s orbital compared to the 6p orbital and rendering it relatively unreactive in ionic compounds. The inert pair effect is less pronounced in compounds where lead forms covalent bonds with elements of similar electronegativity, such as carbon in organolead compounds. In these, the 6s and 6p orbitals remain comparable in size, and sp3 hybridization remains energetically favorable, making lead predominantly tetravalent in such cases. The electronegativity values further reflect this behavior: lead(II) has a value of 1.87, and lead(IV) has 2.33. This represents a reversal in the general trend of increasing stability of the +4 oxidation state down the carbon group; by comparison, tin has electronegativities of 1.80 (+2 state) and 1.96 (+4 state). Some lead compounds exist in formal oxidation states other than +4 or +2. Lead(III) may be obtained, as an intermediate between lead(II) and lead(IV), in larger organolead complexes; this oxidation state is not stable, as both the lead(III) ion and the larger complexes containing it are radicals. The same applies for lead(I), which can be found in such radical species. Numerous mixed lead(II,IV) oxides are known. When PbO2 is heated in air, it becomes Pb12O19 at 293 °C, Pb12O17 at 351 °C, Pb3O4 at 374 °C, and finally PbO at 605 °C. A further sesquioxide, Pb2O3, can be obtained at high pressure, along with several non-stoichiometric phases. Many of them show defective fluorite structures in which some oxygen atoms are replaced by vacancies: PbO can be considered as having such a structure, with every alternate layer of oxygen atoms absent. Negative oxidation states can occur as Zintl phases, as either free lead anions, as in Ba2Pb, with lead formally being lead(−IV), or Lead can form multiply-bonded chains, a property it shares with its lighter homologs in the carbon group. Its capacity to do so is much less because the Pb–Pb bond energy is over three and a half times lower than that of the C–C bond. With itself, lead can build metal–metal bonds of an order up to three. With carbon, lead forms organolead compounds similar to, but generally less stable than, typical organic compounds (due to the Pb–C bond being rather weak). This makes the organometallic chemistry of lead far less wide-ranging than that of tin. Lead predominantly forms organolead(IV) compounds, even when starting with inorganic lead(II) reactants; very few organolead(II) compounds are known. The most well-characterized exceptions are Pb[CH(SiMe3)2]2 and plumbocene. The lead analog of the simplest organic compound, methane, is plumbane. Plumbane may be obtained in a reaction between metallic lead and atomic hydrogen. Two simple derivatives, tetramethyllead and tetraethyllead, are the best-known organolead compounds. These compounds are relatively stable: tetraethyllead only starts to decompose if heated or if exposed to sunlight or ultraviolet light. With sodium metal, lead readily forms an equimolar alloy that reacts with alkyl halides to form organometallic compounds such as tetraethyllead. The oxidizing nature of many organolead compounds is usefully exploited: lead tetraacetate is an important laboratory reagent for oxidation in organic synthesis. Tetraethyllead, once added to automotive gasoline, was produced in larger quantities than any other organometallic compound, and is still widely used in fuel for small aircraft. Other organolead compounds are less chemically stable. For many organic compounds, a lead analog does not exist.
See more details
The analysis

rails:sufficiency:partial_only:for=0+3p:against=0+0p | v55:multi_partial_one_side:lean=lean_partial:for:one_sided

More for · 2
1974 · cited by 0
Department of Chemistry, Himachal Pradesh University, Simla-171001 Manuscript received 30 September 1973; revised 16 April 1974; accepted 24 April 1974 Benzoin (LH) forms compounds of composition MX 3 L with tetrachlorides and tetrabromides of tin and titanium and tetrachlorides of zirconium and silicon; compounds of composition SnI 4 LH in the case of tan tetraiodide while 2,2'-dichlorobenzoin and 2,2'-dinitrobenzoin form compounds of composition MX 4 LH at room temperature. On refluxing compontids of composition MX 2 L 2 are obtained in the case of pure benzoic and of composition MX 3 L in t CHAUDHRY Description Department of Chemistry, Himachal Pradesh University, Simla-171001 Manuscript received 30 September 1973; revised 16 April 1974; accepted 24 April 1974 Benzoin (LH) forms compounds of composition MX 3 L with tetrachlorides and tetrabromides of tin and titanium and tetrachlorides of zirconium and silicon; compounds of composition SnI 4 LH in the case of tan tetraiodide while 2,2'-dichlorobenzoin and 2,2'-dinitrobenzoin form compounds of composition MX 4 LH at room temperature. On refluxing compontids of composition MX 2 L 2 are obtained in the case of pure benzoic and of composition MX 3 L in the case of substituted ben­zoins.
cited by 0
# Why does tin form tin (II) compounds? - Tags: periodic-trends, oxidation-state - Score: 21 - Views: 2,860 - Answers: 1 - Asked by: Corundum (730 rep) - Asked on: Dec 29, 2015 - Last active: Oct 6, 2017 - License: CC BY-SA 3.0 --- ## Question The stability of the +II oxidation state in lead has been widely attributed to the so-called “inert pair effect”: the 6s subshell is stabilized through relativistic contraction due to the near-c speed of its electrons. Now, Pekka Pyykkö states in his [1988 article](http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/cr00085a006) (p. 585) that > In addition to the 6s2 inert pair discussed above, analogous compounds (such as GeO and SnO) are known for rows 4 and 5. While the relativistic 5s stabilization is not entirely negligible, the 4s stabilization due to the “d-block contraction” probably overweighs relativity on row 4. How does the d-block contraction cause a change in valency? I know that due to poor shielding by d electrons, atomic radii across the fourth period don’t increase particularly. But how is it responsible for the increasing stability of the +II oxidation state in group 14 (before getting to lead, where relativistic effects play a signi
Everything we examined (3)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.
  1. Leadreferenceno side taken
  2. Nature of the Complexes of Benzoins with Group (IV) Halidesreferenceno side taken
  3. Why does tin form tin (II) compounds? - Chemistry Stack Exchangereferenceno side taken
The paper trail · every fact has a biography
first checked01 Aug 2026
judged → INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE · 001 Aug 2026
held for human review12 Aug 2026
This receipt carries no identity, shared or not. Sharing publishes your connection to it, not your data.
Check your own claim
Challenge the receipt
trust me, bro: win the argument, pass the class, survive peer review.
This receipt is an automated verdict against our published method · not an opinion about any author or publication.
Terms · Privacy · How verdicts work · Dispute this receipt