A deficit of approximately 7700 calories equals one kilogram of weight loss
the verdict
CONTESTED
contested - the weight sits with the supporting side
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
While some literature cites energy deficit values around 7400 or 7700 kcal per kilogram for weight loss, the classic rules and prediction models for energy deficit have come under intense scrutiny.
The classic rule stating that restricting intake by 3500 kcal/wk will lead to a 1-lb/wk rate of weight loss has come under intense scrutiny. Generally not a component of most weight loss prediction models, the "early" rapid weight loss phase may represent a period during which the energy content of weight change (ΔEC/ΔW) is low and thus does not follow the classic "rule." The current study tested this hypothesis. Dynamic ΔEC/ΔW changes were examined in 23 Comprehensive Assessment of Long-term Effects of Reducing Intake of Energy Study overweight men and women evaluated by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry during weight loss at treatment weeks 4 to 24. Changes from baseline in body energy content were estimated from fat and fat-free mass. Repeated-measures analysis of variance was used to determine if ΔEC/ΔW changed significantly over time. The evaluation was expanded with addition of the Kiel 13-week weight loss study of 75 obese men and women to test with adequate power if there are sex differences in ΔEC/ΔW. The analysis of variance CALERIE time effect was significant (P < .001), with post hoc tests indicating that ΔEC/ΔW (kilocalories per kilogram) increased significantly from week 4 (X ± SEM; 4, 858 ± 388) to 6 (6, 041 ± 376, P < .01) and changed insignificantly thereafter; ΔEC/ΔW was significantly larger for Kiel women (6, 804 ± 226) vs men (6, 119 ± 240, P < .05). Sex-specific dynamic relative changes in body composition and related ΔEC/ΔW occur with weight loss initiation that extend for 1 month or more. These observations provide new information for developing energy balance models and further define limitations of the 3500-kcal energy deficit → 1-lb weight loss rule.
To determine energy density for rapid weight loss (RWL) of weight-classified sports, eight male elite wrestlers were instructed to lose 6% of body mass (BM) within 53 h. Energy deficit during the RWL was calculated by subtracting total energy expenditure (TEE) determined using the doubly labeled water method (DLW) from energy intake (EI) assessed with diet records. It was also estimated from body composition change estimated with the four-component model (4C) and other conventional methods. BM decreased significantly by 4.7 ± 0.5 kg (6.4 ± 0.5%). Total body water loss was the major component of the BM loss (71.0 ± 7.6%). TEE was 9446 ± 1422 kcal, and EI was 2366 ± 1184 kcal during the RWL of 53-h; therefore, the energy deficit was 7080 ± 1525 kcal. Thus, energy density was 1507 ± 279 kcal/kg ∆BM during the RWL, comparable with values obtained using the 4C, three-component model, dual energy X-ray absorptiometry, and stable isotope dilution. Energy density for RWL of wrestlers is lower than that commonly used (7400 or 7700 kcal/kg ΔBM). Although RWL is not recommended, we propose that commonly practiced extreme energy restriction such as 7400 or 7700 kcal/kg ΔBM during RWL appears to be meaningless.
Nutrients Nutrients 1692 nutrients nutrients Nutrients 2072-6643 Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI) PMC5986416 PMC5986416.1 5986416 5986416 29701639 10.3390/nu10050536 nutrients-10-00536 1 Article Energy Deficit Required for Rapid Weight Loss in Elite Collegiate Wrestlers https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9145-0549 Kondo Emi 1 * Sagayama Hiroyuki 1 2 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4284-6317 Yamada Yosuke 3 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1089-9593 Shiose Keisuke 4 Osawa Takuya 5 Motonaga Keiko 1 Ouchi Shiori 1 Kamei Akiko 1 Nakajima Kohei 1 Higaki Yasuki 4 Tanaka Hiroaki 4 Takahashi Hideyuki 1 Okamura Koji 6 1 Japan Institute of Sports Sciences, 3-15-1 Nishigaoka, Kita-ku, Tokyo 115-0056, Japan; hiroyuki.sagayama@jpnsport.go.jp (H.S.); keiko.motonaga@jpnsport.go.jp (K.M.); ouchi.shiori@gmail.com (S.O.);
2018 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ ). To determine energy density for rapid weight loss (RWL) of weight-classified sports, eight male elite wrestlers were instructed to lose 6% of body mass (BM) within 53 h. Energy deficit during the RWL was calculated by subtracting total energy expenditure (TEE) determined using the doubly labeled water method (DLW) from energy intake (EI) assessed with diet records.
It was also estimated from body composition change estimated with the four-component model (4C) and other conventional methods. BM decreased significantly by 4.7 ± 0.5 kg (6.4 ± 0.5%). Total body water loss was the major component of the BM loss (71.0 ± 7.6%). TEE was 9446 ± 1422 kcal, and EI was 2366 ± 1184 kcal during the RWL of 53-h; therefore, the energy deficit was 7080 ± 1525 kcal. Thus, energy density was 1507 ± 279 kcal/kg ∆BM during the RWL, comparable with values obtained using the 4C, three-component model, dual energy X-ray absorptiometry, and stable isotope dilution. Energy density for RWL of wrestlers is lower than that commonly used (7400 or 7700 kcal/kg ΔBM).
Although RWL is not recommended, we propose that commonly practiced extreme energy restriction such as 7400 or 7700 kcal/kg ΔBM during RWL appears to be meaningless. body composition energy balance weight loss doubly labeled water multi-component model pmc-status-qastatus 0 pmc-status-live yes pmc-status-embargo no pmc-status-released yes pmc-prop-open-access yes pmc-prop-olf no pmc-prop-manuscript no pmc-prop-legally-suppressed no pmc-prop-has-pdf yes pmc-prop-has-supplement no pmc-prop-pdf-only no pmc-prop-suppress-copyright no pmc-prop-is-real-version no pmc-prop-is-scanned-article no pmc-prop-preprint no pmc-prop-in-epmc yes pmc-license-ref CC BY 1.
The optimal duration of weight loss before competition is one of the major concerns of athletes, coaches, trainers, strength and conditioning specialists, and nutritional experts. The weight loss for weigh-ins for athletic competitions is sometimes associated with dehydration, resulting in dizziness, vertigo, and lightheadedness; this limits the ability to practice before the competition [ 3 ]. Several weight-classified athletes lose weight rapidly (>5%) during the final few days (2–3 days) before a competition after a long or intermediate period of mild weight loss [ 4 ].
There is limited research on criterion techniques such as the four-component (4C) or three-component (3C) models. Currently, the 4C model is regarded as a criterion method for estimating body composition. However, no previous studies have examined the change of body composition during RWL within 1 week in weight-classified athletes using the 4C model. Moreover, it is unclear regarding the change of body composition and the required energy deficit for RWL over shorter durations (2–3 days) commonly employed by many combat athletes [ 4 ]. Energy loss during BM reduction is calculated as a difference between energy intake (EI) and total energy expenditure (TEE) during BM reduction.
Therefore, it is considered that despite limitations the energy balance was estimated accurately. 5. Conclusions In conclusion, we observed that the energy density of 53-h RWL was 1507 kcal/kg ΔBM. This was because the BM loss was mostly achieved by loss of TBW. Although RWL is not recommended, we propose that commonly practiced extreme energy restriction such as 7400 or 7700 kcal/ΔBM during RWL appears to be meaningless. Our findings show that the energy deficit calculated with the 4C model based on 9500 kcal/kg ΔFM and 1020 kcal/kg ΔFFM is consistent with that evaluated using TEE measured with DLW and EI under this RWL situation.
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.