Written sentences were historically longer than they are in modern writing
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
Linguistic literature and historical studies confirm that written English sentences have steadily decreased in average length over the past few centuries compared to modern writing.
The goal of this paper is threefold: (i) to present some practical aspects of using the full-text version of the
Corpus of Historical American English
(COHA), the largest diachronic multi-genre corpus of the
English language, in the investigation of a linguistic trend of change; (ii) to test a widely held assumption that
sentence length in written English has been steadily decreasing over the past few centuries; (iii) to point to a
possible link between changes in sentence length and changes in English syntactic usage. The empirical proof of
concept for (iii) is provided by the decline in the frequency of the non-finite purpose subordinator
in order
to
. Sentence length, genre and the likelihood of occurrence of
in order to
are shown to
be interrelated.
Variation of sentence length across time and genre
Pre-final submission which appeared as:
Rudnicka, Karolina. 2018. Variation of sentence length across time and genre. In Diachronic
Corpora, Genre, and Language Change [Studies in Corpus Linguistics 85], Richard Jason Whitt
(ed.), 220-240. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
https://www.benjamins.com/catalog/scl.85
Karolina Rudnicka
University of Freiburg
Variation of sentence length across time and genre: influence on the
syntactic usage in English
Abstract
The goal of this paper is threefold: i) to present some practical aspects of using full-text version
of Corpus of Historical American English (COHA) , the largest diachronic multi-genre corpus
of the English language, in the investigation of a linguistic trend of change; ii) to test a widely
held assumption that sentence length in written English has been steadily decreasing over the
past few centuries; iii) to point to a possible link between the changes in sentence length and
changes in the English syntactic usage. The empirical proof of concept for iii) is provided by
the decline in the frequency of the non-finite purpose subordinator in order to. Sentence length,
genre and the likelihood of occurrence of in order to are shown to be interrelated.
Keywords: sentence length; language change; semicolon; mega-corpora; Late Modern English,
in order to
Variation of sentence length across time and genre
On the other hand, it is becoming easier to read “because of its declining sentence length and
number of clauses per sen tence”. The work of Dorgeloh (2005) on patterns of agentivity and
narrativity in early science discourse, adds a few more observations on the development of
language of science from the 15th century to the present, and on the factors that shaped the way
scientific texts look like today. In her work ( 2005: 92) she claims that “ modern science texts
tend to nominalise the experience and to impersonalise the argument ”, whereas in the past it
was typical for the narrative and the argument to be based on personal reference. The
observations concerning the more complex and compact noun phrases and the decrease in the
number of clauses per sentence are further supported by the research of Hundt et al. (2012 :
224), which also focuses on scientific discourse. Additionally, their research notes that the
marked decrease in the frequency of relative clauses coincides with a marked decrease of
sentence length occurring around the beginning of the twentieth century (2012: 225).
A large part of the recent research dealing with sentence length decrease focuses on
newspaper language. Westin (2002) provides statistically significant evidence for this effect in
a wide range of English newspapers, such as The Times, Guardian and Daily Telegraph for the
period 1900 -2000. Additionally to the sentence length itself, she also investigates sentence
length distributions in the texts from particular years. One of the observations she makes is that
“The shortest sentences, from 1 to 10 words, increased in number, from 5.7% in 1900 to 16.6%
in 1993” (Westin 2002: 81). Westin concludes that if we assume there is a relation between
sentence length and sentence complexity, “it is obvious that the complexity of the sentences in
English
Variation of sentence length across time and genre
sentence length decrease, and if the possible explanations for this decrease would be similar
cross-linguistically.
Language Corpora
Davies, Mark. (2008-). The Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA): 520 million
words, 1990-present. Available online at http://corpus.byu.edu/coca/
Davies, M ark. (2010-). The Corpus of Historical American English (COHA): 400 million
words, 1810- 2009. Available online at https://corpus.byu.edu/coha/
References
Biber, Douglas & Conrad, Susan. 2009. Register, Genre, and Style . Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Biber, Douglas & Gray , Bethany. 2010. Challenging stereotypes about academic writing:
Complexity, elaboration, explicitness. Journal of English for Academic Purposes 9, 2-20.
Davis, Edith A. 1937. Mean sentence length compared with long and short sentences as a
reliable measure of language development. Child Development 8(1): 69-79.
Dorgeloh, Heidrun. 2005. Patterns of agentivity and narrativity in early science discourse. In
Opening windows in discourse and texts from the past , Janne Skaffari, Matti Peikola, Ruth
Carroll, Risto Hiltunen & Brita Warvik (eds), 83-94. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: Benjamins.
Fahnestock, Jeanne. 2011. Rhetorical Style: The Uses Of Language In Persuasion. New York:
Oxford University Press.
Fries, Udo. 2010. Sentence Length, Sentence Complexity and the Noun Phrase in 18th-Century
News Publications. In Language Change and Variation from Old English to Late Modern
# Sentence length in English writing in early 1900s vs. English writing now
- Tags: writing-style, historical-change
- Score: 2
- Views: 740
- Answers: 0 (unanswered)
- Asked by: anusha (21 rep)
- Asked on: Jul 8, 2015
- Last active: Jul 8, 2015
---
## Question
I am reading a book called _The Best American Essays of the Century_. One thing I keep noticing is a lot of the sentences in this book are very long — 5 to 6 lines. I read a lot of articles on the web, and the difference is obvious to me. In my opinion, contemporary writers keep their sentences short. Obviously there is not one way to write, but what I learned in college was to not make sentences too long and keep varying the length of sentences — not just too short in particular.
Now coming back to the question. What was the reason for this paradigm shift? I understand languages, including English, evolve over time. What was the main reason(s) behind the change?
---
## Comments
- **Brian Hitchcock** (+1): But nonfiction (especially tech writing) has to get to the point quickly.
- **Brian Hitchcock** (+5): Novels are considered a form of entertainment. The reader is assumed to have time to savor and untangle the lavi
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.