Vagueness and ambiguity serve positive communicative functions in natural language.
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
Linguistic and communication research indicates that both vagueness and ambiguity perform constructive roles, such as driving communicative strategies, facilitating innovations, and engaging listener participation.
Abstract
In linguistic research, the concepts of ambiguity and
vagueness are often confused and frequently invoked to describe
synchronic facts and explain diachronic processes. This article
illustrates the differences and similarities between the two
phenomena, defines their position within the domain of semantic
indeterminacy, and discusses their role in linguistic change. The
examples show that while ambiguity is intertwined with various
mechanisms of change, acting as both a source and a product of
innovation, vagueness plays a marginal role, being mainly a side
effect of ongoing change or a tool of communicative strategies of
vague language. Moreover, intentional vagueness usually promotes
speaker-driven innovations, whereas ambiguity can trigger
hearer-driven changes that unfold broader diachronic scenarios.
... communicate , " he stated emphatically ; " that vagueness and ambiguity can fill a variety of positive functions . " " Okay ; I was just teasing , " she confessed . " I agree with you . The vague- ness and ambiguity in spirituality talk ...
This book develops a new and innovative way of understanding how language is used when people describe their spiritual and mystical encounters. Early chapters provide overviews of the nature of spiritual encounters, how commonly they occur, and the role of language. The book then develops a unique way of understanding the dynamics of talking about spirituality, using original research to support this perspective. In particular, Peter J. Adams explores how this characteristically vague way of speaking can be viewed as an intentional and not an incidental aspect of such communications because certain types of vagueness have the capacity to engage the imaginative participation of receptive listeners. This expressive vagueness is achieved by embedding missing bits, or “gaps,” in the flow of wh
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.