Upwards lightning uses a single path while downward lightning uses multiple stepped leader paths
the verdict
CONTESTED
contested - the weight sits with the supporting side
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
4 sources for · 0 against
While downward stepped leaders are documented to branch into multiple paths, studies also show that multiple upward leaders can initiate and compete during attachments, contradicting the claim that upward lightning uses only a single path.
Abstract Using visible‐range and infrared (3–5 µm) high‐speed video cameras, we observed collisions of adjacent branches in downward negative stepped leaders. Typically, a lagging (chasing) branch (CB) approached a leading branch (LB) from aside at about 90° angle and connected to the lateral surface of the LB within some tens of meters or less of its tip. We infer that collisions can be facilitated by the attracting force of upward moving positive‐charge wave associated with stepping at the leading branch tip. Outcomes of branch collisions differ. The chasing branch may be absorbed by the LB, rebound, or temporarily bridge two branches. It appears that a heavily branched negative stepped leader creates a highly structured and rapidly changing electric field pattern inside the volume it occupies. We observed abrupt changes in the direction of branch extension, suggesting that the direction of local electric field can differ significantly from the ambient.
AbstractUpward negative leaders (UNLs) in positive upward lightning are rarely observed. In this study, 24 UNLs observed by the Fast Antenna Lightning Mapping Array during winter thunderstorms in Japan are analyzed. Three‐dimensional velocities of UNLs are calculated, and it is found that velocities during the upward propagation stage range from 1.8 to 27.9 × 105 m/s with a mean value of 10.4 × 105 m/s, and they are always larger than velocities during the following horizontal propagation stage. UNLs produce distinctive electric field change waveforms with V‐shaped overall change trend, with small pulses at the beginning when UNLs start, large pulses during upward propagations, and small pulses again when UNLs turn into horizontal directions. Pulses produced by UNLs are mainly unipolar but sometimes also bipolar. Pulse interval, pulse width, rise time, and fall time are calculated for waveforms produced by five UNLs. Pulse intervals range from 13.7 to 18.9 μs. Pulse width, rise time, and fall time are on average 5.8, 3.3, and 2.4 μs, respectively. All UNLs are preceded by other discharges. Strong negative strokes including some special types of strokes usually precede initiations of UNLs by tens of milliseconds. These negative strokes are usually found only a few kilometers away from UNLs. It is speculated that these negative strokes along with following in‐cloud positive leaders contribute to the depletion of negative charges in thunderclouds, which result in positive electric field changes (atmospheric electricity sign convention) large enough for initiations of UNLs.
In this paper we analyze electric-field and current measurements of
competing upward leaders induced by a downward negative lightning flash
that struck a residential building. The attachment process was recorded
by two high-speed cameras running at 37,800 and 70,000 images per second
and the current measured in two lightning rods. Differently from
previous works, here we show, for the first time, the behavior of
multiple upward leaders that after initiation compete to connect the
negative downward moving leader. At the beginning of the propagation of
the leaders that initiate on the instrumented lightning rods, current
pulses appear superimposed to a steadily increasing DC current. The
upward leader current pulses increase with the approach of the downward
leader and are not synchronized but present an alternating pattern. All
leader speeds are constant. The upward leaders are slower than the
downward leader speed. The average time interval between current pulses
in upward leaders is close to the interstep time interval found by
optical or electric field sensors for negative cloud-to-ground stepped
leaders. The upward leaders respond to different downward propagating
branches and, as the branches alternate in propagation and intensity, so
do the leaders accordingly. Right before the attachment process the
alternating pattern of the leaders ceases, all downward leader branches
intensify, and consequently upward leaders synchronize and pulse
together. The average linear densities for upward leaders (49 and 82
µC/m) were obtained for the first time for natural lightning.
Cloud-to-ground (CG) lightning is a lightning discharge between a thundercloud and the ground. It is initiated by a stepped leader moving down from the
Lightning is a natural phenomenon consisting of electrostatic discharges occurring through the atmosphere between two electrically charged regions. One or both regions are within the atmosphere, with the second region sometimes occurring on the ground. Following the lightning, the regions become partially or wholly electrically neutralized.
Lightning involves a near-instantaneous release of energy
C…
In a process not well understood, a bidirectional channel of ionized air, called a "leader", is initiated between oppositely-charged regions in a thundercloud. Leaders are electrically conductive channels of ionized gas that propagate through, or are otherwise attracted to, regions with a charge opposite of that of the leader tip. The negative end of the bidirectional leader fills a positive charge region, also called a well, inside the cloud while the positive end fills a negative charge well. Leaders often split, forming branches in a tree-like pattern. In addition, negative and some positive leaders travel in a discontinuous fashion, in a process called "stepping". The resulting jerky movement of the leaders can be readily observed in slow-motion videos of lightning flashes.
It is possible for one end of the leader to fill the oppositely-charged well entirely while the other end is still active. When this happens, the leader end which filled the well may propagate outside of the thundercloud and result in either a cloud-to-air flash or a cloud-to-ground flash. In a typical cloud-to-ground flash, a bidirectional leader initiates between the main negative and lower positive charge regions in a thundercloud. The weaker positive charge region is filled quickly by the negative leader which then propagates toward the inductively-charged ground.
The positively and negatively charged leaders proceed in opposite directions,
In a process not well understood, a bidirectional channel of ionized air, called a "leader", is initiated between oppositely-charged regions in a thundercloud. Leaders are electrically conductive channels of ionized gas that propagate through, or are otherwise attracted to, regions with a charge opposite of that of the leader tip. The negative end of the bidirectional leader fills a positive charge region, also called a well, inside the cloud while the positive end fills a negative charge well. Leaders often split, forming branches in a tree-like pattern. In addition, negative and some positive leaders travel in a discontinuous fashion, in a process called "stepping". The resulting jerky movement of the leaders can be readily observed in slow-motion videos of lightning flashes.
It is possible for one end of the leader to fill the oppositely-charged well entirely while the other end is still active. When this happens, the leader end which filled the well may propagate outside of the thundercloud and result in either a cloud-to-air flash or a cloud-to-ground flash. In a typical cloud-to-ground flash, a bidirectional leader initiates between the main negative and lower positive charge regions in a thundercloud. The weaker positive charge region is filled quickly by the negative leader which then propagates toward the inductively-charged ground.
The positively and negatively charged leaders proceed in opposite directions, positive upwards within the cloud and negative towards the earth. Both ionic channels proceed, in their respective directions, in a number of successive spurts. Each leader "pools" ions at the leading tips, shooting out one or more new leaders, momentarily pooling again to concentrate charged ions, then shooting out another leader. The negative leader continues to propagate and split as it heads downward, often speeding up as it gets closer to the Earth's surface.
About 90% of ionic channel lengths between "pools" are approximately 45 m (148 ft) in length. The establishment of the ionic channel takes a comparatively long amount of time (hundreds of milliseconds) in comparison to the resulting discharge, which occurs within a few dozen microseconds. The electric current needed to establish the channel, measured in the tens or hundreds of amperes, is dwarfed by subsequent currents during the actual discharge.
Initiation of the lightning leader is not well understood. The electric field strength within the thundercloud is not typically large enough to initiate this process by itself. Many hypotheses have been proposed. One hypothesis postulates that showers of relativistic electrons are created by cosmic rays and are then accelerated to higher velocities via a process called runaway breakdown. As these relativistic electrons collide and ionize neutral air molecules, they initiate leader formation. Another hypothesis involves locally enhanced electric fields being formed near elongated water droplets or ice crystals. Percolation theory, especially for the case of biased percolation, describes random connectivity phenomena, which produce an evolution of connected structures similar to that of lightning strikes. A streamer avalanche model has recently been favored by observational data taken by LOFAR during storms.
Because the electrostatic discharge of terrestrial lightning superheats the air to plasma temperatures along the length of the discharge channel in a short duration, kinetic theory dictates gaseous molecules undergo a rapid increase in pressure and thus expand outward from the lightning creating a shock wave audible as thunder. Since the sound waves propagate not from a single point source but along the length of the lightning's path, the sound origin's varying distances from the observer can generate a rolling or rumbling effect. Perception of the sonic characteristics is further complicated by factors such as the irregular and possibly branching geometry of the lightning channel, by acoustic echoing
Everything we examined (5) — 4 independent sources
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.