Two ultra-relativistic billiard balls forming a black hole when they just miss
the verdict
INSUFFICIENT LEANING
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
The retrieved peer-reviewed literature partially supports the theoretical possibility that ultra-relativistic particle collisions at close impact parameters can form black holes, but does not specifically address macroscopic billiard balls.
We numerically investigate the formation of D-dimensional black holes in high-energy particle collision with the impact parameter and evaluate the total cross section of the black hole production. We find that the formation of an apparent horizon occurs when the distance between the colliding particles is less than 1.5 times the effective gravitational radius of each particles. Our numerical result indicates that although both the one-dimensional hoop and the (D-3)-dimensional volume corresponding to the typical scale of the system give a fairly good condition for the horizon formation in the higher-dimensional gravity, the (D-3)-dimensional volume provide a better condition to judge the existence of the horizon.
I. INTRODUCTION
The brane world scenario is paid much attention in the context of the unified theory
of elementary particles. This scenario regards our space as the 3- brane with large extra
dimensions on which gauge particles and interactions are confined. I n this scenario, the
Planck energy can be at the O(TeV) scale [1]. One of the consequences of lowering the
Planck scale is that the properties of a small black hole whose radius is smaller than the
size of the extra dimensions are substantially altered; the black hole s is well-described as
a D-dimensional black hole centered on the brane, but extending out in to the ( D − 4)-
dimensional extra space and the radius of such a black hole is ∼ 1032 times larger than that
of the usual black hole with the same mass. Hence it becomes much ea sier to produce black
holes using a future planned accelerator such as the CERN Large Ha dron Collider and this
possibility has been discussed by many authors [2].
The possibility of producing black holes by the collision of particles can b e estimated
by using the hoop conjecture [3], which states that an apparent ho rizon forms when and
only when the mass M of the system gets compacted into a region whose circumference C
satisfies
HD ≡ C
2πrh(M) ≲ 1, (1)
where rh(M) is the Schwarzschild horizon radius for the mass M. If we assume that the
inequality (1) give the condition for black hole formation in the higher- dimensional gravity,
we can evaluate the impact parameter b of the colliding particles which leads to black
hole production. The circumference that surrounds two particles at the instant of collision
is C ∼ 2b. By setting 2 b/2πrh(2µ) ∼ 1 where 2 µ is the center of mass energy of the
system, the maximal impact parameter bmax that leads to the black hole formation becomes
bmax ∼ rh(2µ). By introducing a numerical factor F (D) close to unity, the total cross section
for black hole production is written as the following form:
σb.h.production = F (D)πr 2
h(2µ). (2)
Obtaining F (D) is necessary to improve experimental predictions of the black hole produc-
tion in collider physics and observations of ultra-high energy cosmic r ays.
In our previous paper [4], we investigated the black hole formation in h igh-energy head-on
collisions of particles in the D-dimensional gravity and found that HD becomes a parameter
2
geometry of the extra dimensions. The metric with a high-energy po int particle is obtained
by infinitely boosting a Schwarzschild black hole with fixed total energ y µ. The result-
ing system becomes a massless point particle accompanied by a plane- fronted gravitational
shock wave which is the Lorentz-contracted longitudinal gravitat ional field of the particle.
Combining two shock waves, we can set up the collision of high-energy two particles moving
in ±z direction. This system was originally developed by D’Eath and Payne [7] and recently
analyzed in [4, 6]. The metric of this system outside the future light co ne of the colliding
shocks is given as
ds2 = −dudv +
(
H (+)
ik H (+)
jk + H (−)
ik H (−)
jk − δij
)
dxidxj,
H (+)
ij = δij + u
2 Θ( u)∇i∇jΦ( x − x+), (4)
H (−)
ij = δij + v
2 Θ( v)∇i∇jΦ( x − x−),
where u = t − z, v = t + z, Θ is the Heviside step function and x ≡ (xi) is the point in
flat ( D − 2)-space ( x1, · · · , xD−2) that is transverse to the direction of particle motion. The
function Φ( x) depends only on r ≡ |x| =
√
xixi and takes the form
Φ( x) = −8G4µ log r, for D = 4 (5)
Φ( x) = 16πµGD
Ω D−3(D − 4)
1
rD−4 , for D > 4 (6)
where Ω D−3 is the volume of a unit ( D − 3)-sphere and x± denote the points of two particles
in ( D − 2)-dimensional space and we take
x± = ( ±b/2,
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 D
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
bmax rh(2 )µ
FIG. 3: The value of bmax (crosses) as a function of the spacetime dimension D. The dotted line
rh(2µ) which comes from the hoop conjecture. Although the ratio bmax/rh(2µ) takes the value
around unity, the hoop conjecture does not explain the incre ase of bmax/rh(2µ) with D. The solid
line bmax/rh(2µ) = 1 .5rh(µ)/rh(2µ) ∼ 2−1/ (D−3) gives a good fit of bmax.
can be written as
HD ≡
[ VD−3
Ω D−3rD−3
h (M)
]1/ (D−3)
≲ 1. (18)
This condition reduces to the hoop conjecture (1) for D = 4 case. As the characteristic
length of the system is b in x1-direction and rh(µ) in other directions, the characteristic
(D − 3)-volume becomes VD−3 ∼ b rD−4
h (µ) and HD becomes ∼
[
brD−4
h (µ)/rD−3
h (2µ)
]1/ (D−3)
.
By setting HD ∼ 1, the maximal impact parameter is given by
bmax
rh(2µ) ∼
( rh(2µ)
rh(µ)
) D−4
∝ 2−1/ (D−3). (19)
Although this is rough order estimation, the calculation indicates tha t the volume conjecture
provides a better condition than the hoop conjecture.
To test the validity of the two conjectures further, we consider h ow much energy is
trapped by the black hole. This is related to the definition of the mass in the system. In
our previous paper [8], we discussed the existence of the gravitatio nal wave energy that
does not contribute to the horizon formation in the system with mot ion and found that the
hoop conjecture with Hawking’s quasilocal mass provides a good con dition for the horizon
formation in four-dimensional gravity. In the present system, we calculate the quantity
MA.H. ≡ (D − 2)Ω D−2
16πGD
( AD−2
Ω D−2
) (D−3)/ (D−2)
, (20)
9
This paper introduces a new effort to study the collision of plane-fronted gravitational waves in four dimensional, asymptotically flat spacetime, using numerical solutions of the Einstein equations. The pure vacuum problem requires singular, Aichelburg-Sexl type sources to achieve finite energy solutions, which are problematic to treat both mathematically and numerically. Instead then, we use null (massless) particles to source non-trivial geometry within the initial wave fronts. The main purposes of this paper are to (a) motivate the problem, (b) introduce methods for numerically solving the Einstein equations coupled to distributions of collisionless massless or massive particles, and (c) present a first result on the formation of black holes in the head-on collision of axisymmetric distributions of null particles. Regarding the last-named, initial conditions are chosen so that a black hole forms promptly, with essentially no matter escaping the collision. This can be interpreted as approaching the ultra-relativistic collision problem from within an infinite boost limit, but where the matter distribution is spread out, and thus non-singular. We find results that are consistent with earlier perturbative calculations of the collision of Aichelburg-Sexl singularities, as well as numerical studies of the high-speed collision of boson stars, black holes, and fluid stars: a black hole is formed containing most of the energy of the spacetime, with the remaining $15\pm1\%$ of the initial energy radiated away as gravitational waves. The methods developed here could be relevant for other problems in strong field gravity and cosmology that involve particle distributions of matter.
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.