Transition elements form colored compounds due to d-d electron transitions
the verdict
CONTESTED
contested - the weight sits with the supporting side
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
AS REPORTEDno primary record reached; this is what the reporting says
The provided sources discuss factors influencing metal complex colors and electronic energy spacings, but do not establish that d-d electron transitions are the cause.
The color of the transition metal complex solution is dependent on: the metal, the metal oxidation state, and the number of metal d-electrons. For example iron(II) complexes are green and iron(III) complexes are orange/brown.2
Charge Transfer Bands
If color is dependent on d-d transitions, why is it that some transition metal complexes are intensely colored in solution but possess no d electrons? In transition metal complexes a change in electron distribution between the metal and a ligand give rise to charge transfer (CT) bands.1 CT absorptions in the UV/Vis region are intense (ε values of 50,000 L mole-1 cm-1 or greater) and selection rule allowed. The intensity of the color is due to the fact that there is a high probability of these transitions taking place. Selection rule forbidden d-d transitions result in weak absorptions. For example octahedral complexes give ε values of 20 L mol-1 cm-1 or less.2 A charge transfer transition can be regarded as an internal oxidation-reduction process. 2
Ligand to Metal and Metal to Ligand Charge Transfer Bands
Ligands possess \(σ\), \(σ^*\), \(π\), \(π^*\), and nonbonding (\(n\)) molecular orbitals.
Every different compound will have unique energy spacing between electronic levels, and depending on the type of compound, one can categorize these spacings and find some commonality. For example, aromatic compounds pi to pi* and n to pi* transitions where as inorganic compounds can have similar transitions with Metal to Ligand Charge Transfer (MLCT) and Ligand to Metal Charge Transfer (LMCT) in addition to d-d transitions, which lead to the bright colors of transition metal complexes. Although surprises in science often lead to discovery, it is more fortuitous for the interpreter to predict the spectra rather than being baffled by the observation. The following section will discuss the interpretation of electronic absorption spectra given the nature of the chemical species being studied. This includes an understanding of the molecular or elemental electronic state symmetries, Russell-Sanders states, spin multiplicities, and forbidden and allowed transitions of a given species. As the light passes through the monochrometer of the spectrophotometer, it hits the sample with some wavelength and corresponding energy.
Everything we examined (2) — 1 independent source
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.