Space agencies maintain protocols and specialized medical kits for emergency surgery in microgravity.
the verdict
INSUFFICIENT LEANING
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
3 sources for · 0 against
The evidence discusses general medical preparations, specialized kits, and protocols for managing specific medical contingencies such as ocular injuries and dental issues during space missions, but it does not fully establish protocols or kits specifically dedicated to emergency surgery in microgravity.
Ocular trauma or other ocular conditions can be significantly debilitating in space. A literature review of over 100 articles and NASA evidence books, queried for eye related trauma, conditions, and exposures was conducted. Ocular trauma and conditions during NASA space missions during the Space Shuttle Program and ISS through Expedition 13 in 2006 were reviewed. There were 70 corneal abrasions, 4 dry eyes, 4 eye debris, 5 complaints of ocular irritation, 6 chemical burns, and 5 ocular infections noted. Unique exposures on spaceflight, such as foreign bodies, including celestial dust, which may infiltrate the habitat and contact the ocular surface, as well as chemical and thermal injuries due to prolonged CO2 and heat exposure were reported. Diagnostic modalities used to evaluate the above conditions in space flight include vision questionnaires, visual acuity and Amsler grid testing, fundoscopy, orbital ultrasound, and ocular coherence tomography. Several types of ocular injuries and conditions, mostly affecting the anterior segment, are reported. Further research is necessary to understand the greatest ocular risks that astronauts face and how better we can prevent, but also diagnose and treat these conditions in space.
3205 npjmicrogr NPJ Microgravity NPJ Microgravity Nature Publishing Group PMC10188687 10188687 10188687 37193709 10.1038/s41526-023-00279-y Ocular conditions and injuries, detection and management in spaceflight Meer Elana 1 2 Grob Seanna 1 Antonsen Erik L 3 Sawyer Aenor 2 4 ✉ 1 Department of Ophthalmology, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA USA 2 University of California Space Health Program, San Francisco, CA USA 3 Department of Emergency Medicine and Center for Space Medicine, Baylor College of Medicine, Houstan, Texas USA 4 Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA USA ✉ Corresponding author.
Characterization of ocular injuries and conditions in space The Exploration Medical Conditions List at NASA has been the source of medical conditions considered for probabilistic risk analysis regarding medical risk in the past 10 . This list has historically included four eye specific conditions: Eye Chemical Burn, Eye Corneal Ulcer, Eye Infection, and Retinal Detachment. In one assessment, Eye Chemical Burn was the top influential medical condition contributing to the probability of evacuation for certain ISS mission conditions 10 .
Table 1 Medical condition and symptomatology during NASA Space Missions Obtained from Lifetime Surveillance of Astronaut Health (LSAH) records for medical conditions that occurred among US astronauts during the Space Shuttle Program and ISS through Expedition 13 in 2006. Medical Condition/Symptoms Number of Events Eye Abnormality unspecified 9 Eye Debris 4 Dry Eyes 4 Eye Irritation 5 Puffy eyes 1 Eye Abrasion (Foreign Body) 70 Eye Chemical Burn 6 Eye Infection 5 Data derived extracted from NASA Evidence books 4 .
On a macroscopic level, choroidal folds, cephalad fluid shifts and edema, and globe flattening have been described in the literature, as well as a multitude of microscopic effects due to a combination of microgravity and environmental stressors 36 . Space flight elicits gene expression and histologic changes by inducing oxidative and cellular stress responses in the mouse retina affecting the expression of multiple genes responsible for triggering a protective response 33 , 37 , 53 – 56 .
Exacerbating this predisposition are the many pressure stressors astronauts undergo in the setting of microgravity, pressurized space suits, and high resistance exercise 57 . Persons who are older, have high myopia, history of eye trauma or prior eye surgery, or family history of retinal detachment are also at higher risk for retinal tear in general, unrelated to spaceflight. Diagnosis and treatment Retinal examination to evaluate for retinal tears or other retinal pathology requires a complete dilated fundoscopic examination with scleral depression to visualize peripherally to the ora serrata. On ISS this may be challenging given the lack of equipment and ophthalmologic training.
While not classically an “injury,” it is important to discuss as certain key components of the space flight environment may increase the risk of this sight threatening condition. Potential causes of injury and known data on injury in spaceflight As described, there are several metabolic changes underlying changes in the vasculature of the retina 58 . These changes in vessel caliber and density may be compounded by hypercoagulability in space 59 – 61 , increasing the risk for occlusion of the retina, an ophthalmologic emergency.
Ocular chemical burn Definition Ocular chemical burns may occur secondary to a corrosive substance being introduced into the eye or periocular tissue. Potential causes of injury and known data on injury in spaceflight Prolonged Co2 exposure in space flight may lead to ocular toxicity 64 . This is exacerbated by the reduced air convection in microgravity leading to local pockets of C02 developing around the nose and mouth and facial area 57 . In probabilistic analysis of medical risks, eye chemical burn and burns secondary to fire are the most likely environmental causes of medical illness leading to evacuation on ISS to earth 10 .
As needs for crew autonomy increase with distance from Earth, strategies must be developed to ensure that the acute response to ocular medical issues will be as robust as possible. Protective/preventative measures Given the potential for considerable short-term symptoms and long-term effects of ocular injury in space, preventative measures have been the cornerstone of medical care for astronauts to date. Protective eyewear (Goggles) The emergency eyewash system design includes a pair of swim goggles and tubing to allow for high flow water eyewash delivery. During EVAs, crew members wear two-piece semi-rigid spacesuits.
In February 1968, NASA purchased 400 antigravity ballpoint pens from the Fisher Pen Company for the Apollo Program to prevent potential harm to astronauts and equipment. Mechanical pencils previously used in microgravity posed risks like eye injuries from floating fragments penetrating the cornea. The cornea is vulnerable to abrasions, perforations, and chemical burns in such environments, affecting crewmembers aboard the International Space Station (ISS). While they undergo extensive training for emergency situations, there are inherent complexities when faced with eye injuries. In this challenging context, adapting available medications and leveraging emergency medical training is critical for addressing ocular injuries in a high-stakes environment. This paper explores ISS medications and management strategies for corneal injuries, highlighting the need to include effective medications and countermeasures in future ISS medical kits.
Mechanical pencils previously used in microgravity posed risks like eye injuries from floating fragments penetrating the cornea. The cornea is vulnerable to abrasions, perforations, and chemical burns in such environments, affecting crewmembers aboard the International Space Station (ISS). While they undergo extensive training for emergency situations, there are inherent complexities when faced with eye injuries. In this challenging context, adapting available medications and leveraging emergency medical training is critical for addressing ocular injuries in a high-stakes environment.
The unique environment of space poses risks beyond what may be expected in a terrestrial setting, thus warranting additional safety precautions and medical preparations 7 . Moreover, seeking professional healthcare following ocular injuries becomes exceptionally challenging, especially when return to Earth in a timely manner is not feasible. Aside from such special protocols for ocular injury, supplies are severely limited on the ISS 8 , 9 . First and foremost, the cost of launching supplies to low Earth orbit is exorbitantly high at around $5000 to $25,000 per kilogram 10 .
Limited supply space on the ISS further compounds the issue, necessitating efficient and effective utilization of available cargo space. Many medications require specific conditions of storage (e.g., controlled temperatures, humidity), which can be challenging to maintain in the strict space station environment 11 . Extended missions or delays in resupply missions can also potentially lead to expired or ineffective medications. Consequently, a meticulous selection and management of medications and supplies is necessary to ensure the vital support and well-being of ISS astronauts 12 . Some materials in the medical kit checklist may also not have the primary function as an “eye” medication.
According to NASA’s Space Medicine Operations Division, no changes have been made to the ocular medications since the publication of the 2015 medical kit list ( https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/medical_kit_checklist_-_full_release.pdf ), with the sole exception of a reduction in Cylogyl (Cyclopentolate) concentration from 2 to 1%. The microgravity environment also adds another layer of difficulty to ocular injury management, as a trained eye care professional is unlikely to be present on the ISS, although some crewmembers may hold medical qualifications 51 , 52 .
In this challenging context, adapting available medications and leveraging emergency medical training is critical for addressing ocular injuries in a high-stakes environment 16 . Corneal abrasions during spaceflight Risk factors for corneal abrasions during spaceflight Future planetary missions will likely involve crewmembers being exposed to celestial dust and other particles, increasing the risk of ocular foreign body entry or corneal abrasions. Moreover, microgravity conditions result in suspended particulate matter that can enter crewmembers’ eyes through air currents within the aircraft 53 , 54 .
Crucial resources (e.g., bandage contact lenses, amniotic membrane, corneal transplantation) are not available due to the constrained space and limited specialized medical personnel on board to address the corneal perforations comprehensively. Furthermore, delayed medical consultations due to communication latency pose a significant concern if corneal perforations were to occur, particularly for the extended and distant missions planned in the Artemis Program or future Mars expeditions. Such delays may exacerbate conditions, compromising the success of interventions.
While SANS findings are primarily located in the posterior segment of the eye, it will be of utmost importance to take into consideration all the various factors that impact overall eye health in microgravity. As NASA and other space agencies look ahead for future interplanetary travel, new challenges and ocular threats emerge. Lunar dust, for instance, may expose astronauts to irritants, especially when long-term human habitats of the Moon are constructed under the Artemis Program 78 . Similarly, the Martian surface’s unpredictable and unknown weather patterns can endanger astronauts and their ocular health, warranting robust medical preparations.
Communication latency will present a distinctive challenge in possible emergency scenarios, as flight surgeons and ophthalmologists will be unable to provide real-time guidance for the treatment of ocular injuries. In light of these challenges, proactive protocols for corneal injuries aboard the ISS and interplanetary missions are beyond essential. Just as NASA purchased antigravity ballpoint pens to protect the well-being of astronauts, future missions will need to proactively address the expansive possibilities of corneal injuries. In the future, specialized medical kits will need compact and portable treatment modalities and diagnostic technologies.
Pharmacologic considerations for Shuttle astronauts.
Medication usage by crewmembers in the preflight and inflight mission periods is common in the Shuttle Program. The most common medical reports for which medication is used are: space motion sickness (SMS), sleeplessness, headache, and backache. A number of medications are available in the Shuttle Medical Kit to treat these problems. Currently, astronauts test all frequently used medications before mission assignment to identify potential side-effects, problems related to performance, personal likes/dislikes, and individual therapeutic effect. However, microgravity-induced changes in drug pharmacokinetics, in combination with multiple operational factors, may significantly alter crew-member responses inflight. This article discusses those factors that may impact pharmacologic efficacy during Shuttle missions.
Published in Journal of clinical pharmacology (1991)
Everything we examined (3)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.