Soil creep and gravitational forces cause forests of permanently bent trees.
the verdict
CONTESTED
contested - the weight sits with the supporting side
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
Available research confirms that slope movements can deform tree trunks, but it provides only partial support regarding the specific combination of soil creep and gravitational forces forming permanently bent forests.
Bent trees have been observed during the early years in juvenile plantations (less than 5 years-old) of Tectona grandis in Costa Rica. The relationship between bending and the morphological characteristics of the trees was explored. An evaluation of bent trees was conducted in six juvenile plantations (8, 17, 27, 28, 31, and 54 months old) of Tectona grandis. Site 1 with 8-month-old plantations did not display any relationship with any tree morphological variable (diameter, height, and crown weight of tree), whereas for the sites 2, 3, and 4 with 17-, 27-, and 28-month-old plantations, respectively, all the tree morphological variables were statistically correlated with the bent trees. A multiple regression analysis showed that the most influential variables were height to crown base, crown weight, diameter, and total height of the tree. An evaluation of the bending risk factor (RF) was correlated with the height to crown base, crown weight, and form factor. The modulus of elasticity and chemical compositions of bent trees differed from those of straight trees. The causes of tree bending are complex, involving, among other factors, the morphology of the trees, plantation conditions, and other factors specific to the xylem, such as the specific gravity, modulus of elasticity, and presence of calcium and magnesium in the wood.
Movement of terrain on slopes, unless intense, as in the case of landslides, is practically imperceptible and the deformed trunks of trees growing on slopes are detectors of these movements. The deformation of a tree trunk may therefore be considered as a continuous record of terrain movement for the period of tree vegetation life. The cause of trunk deformation is a slight change in the inclination of the terrain on slope that accompanies terrain movement, and to which the tree trunk adapts during its time growth development. Submitted article presents a proposal for a method that, based on the time dependence of the development of the curvature of a tree trunk, allows a calculation of the path length and rate of the slope terrain movement for either the whole or a particular time period respectively. The calculation of the path length of the terrain movement assumes that the horizontal position of the center of gravity of the tree trunk remains unchanged in time and space, and the horizontal component of the terrain movement path is given by the horizontal distance of the center of gravity of the tree trunk from the heel of the trunk. The rate of movement is calculated from the terrain movement path length and age of the tree, which is determined from the diameter of the trunk. The position of the trunk's center of gravity is calculated from the digitized shape of the trunk according to the principles of solid body mechanics.
2
Calculation of Slope Terrain Movement Rate from Tree Trunk
Deformation
Karel Vojtasik
Department of Geotechnics and Underground Engineering, VSB -Technical University of Ostrava,
Ostrava, 708 00, Czech Republic
karel.vojtasik@vsb.cz
April 2026
Abstract Movement of terrain on slopes, unless intense, as in the case of landslides, is practically
imperceptible and the deformed trunks of trees growing on slopes are detectors of these movements. The
deformation of a tree trunk may therefore be considered as a continuous record of terrain movement for
the period of tree vegetation life. The cause of trunk deformation is a slight change in the inclination of
the terrain on slope that accompanies terrain movement, and to which the tree trunk adapts during its time
growth development . Submitted article presents a proposal for a method that, based on the time
dependence of the development of the curvature of a tree trunk , allows a calculation of the path length
and rate of the slope terrain movement for either the whole or a particular tim e period respectively. The
calculation of the path length of the terrain movement assumes that the horizontal position of the center
of gravity of the tree trunk remains unchanged in time and space, and the horizontal component of the
terrain movement path is given by the horizontal distance of the center of gravity of the tree trunk from
the heel of the trunk. The rate of movement is calculated from the terrain movement path length and age
of the tree, which is determined from the diameter of the trunk. The position of the trunk's center of gravity
is calculated from the digitized shape of the trunk according to the principles of solid body mechanics.
Keywords slope, terrain, movement, rate, deformation, tree trunk
1 Introduction
Terrain movement is a phenomenon seen commonly on the Earth's surface. The innate incentive of terrain
movement is gravity boosted by hydrodynamic forces of groundwater flowing through the terrain. In
addition to these factors, movement is influenced by ge omorphology, terrain slope, terrain profile and
vegetation (Clague and Stead 2012). Human activity can contribute to terrain movement too and it can it
initiate or make it more intensive. The terrain movement intensity in general can vary widely, ranging
from barely noticeable creep to significant ground shifts like landslides. Terrain movement classifications
are assessed through various methodologies (Selley et al., 2005; Rollins and Zekkos, 2012) and some are
based on a rate of terrain movement. Unlike s ubjective descriptive verbal methods of assessing terrain
13
Figure 9: Graph of trunk axis.
Up to the age of 24 years, the terrain slope increases (see Fig. 1 b). After 24 years till the present
time there is a barely noticeable change of the course of the trunk axis, but it generally points at negligible
decrease of terrain slope (see Fig. 1 a).
The calculation of the tree rate movement in the intervals of tree growth, as well as the extent of
this interval, depends on the value of the annual increment of the trunk diameter, which is taken constant,
though in fact it could be affect by some other factors. Thus both the time intervals and respective
calculated rates of terrain movement could be seen as only approximate. Improving the result would
require individual determination of the age of individual sections of the trunk according to tree rings,
which is theoretically possible, but in reality impractical.
The development of the rate of terrain movement demonstrates the general effect of trees in
stabilizing slopes prone to sliding. With expanding of a root net the terrain is progressi vely reinforced.
With increasing age of tree there in the terrain develops natural structure acting similarly like a
gravitational wall.
In the example, a coniferous tree with a single trunk is analysed. This approach could also be used
for deciduous trees with multiple trunk branches. In such a case, however, there is in the analysis need to
create a fictitious stem that substitutes all trunk branches. This additional substitution makes the analysis
difficult but does not disqualify it from determining the rate of terrain movement.
The shape of the tree trunk might result from many other factors beyond terrain movement, like
irregular growth of the tree's canopy due to prevailing wind patterns, obstruction from nearby objects
casting a shadow on it, and po tentially human activities. Before applying this
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.