Qualia function as state variables rather than input variables of the mind.
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
Recent theoretical frameworks in consciousness studies formalize qualia and subjective feelings as internal state equations or internal substrate states rather than direct external inputs.
# A Mechanistic Conditioning Model of Feeling and Qualia ## Core Postulate Assume every adaptive system possesses: - A substrate capable of changing internal state. - A mechanism for recording the consequences of interactions with reality. - A mechanism for replaying successful or unsuccessful adaptive responses when sufficiently similar conditions recur. No additional primitive called "feeling" is introduced. --- ## Definitions Let: - Rₜ = reality input at time t - Sₜ = substrate state - M = accumulated memory of previous interactions - C = conditioning function - P = preparation cascade - Aₜ = action Learning is defined as: Mₜ₊₁ = C(Mₜ, Rₜ, outcome) The substrate continuously modifies itself according to interaction outcomes. --- ## Preparation Replay When a sufficiently similar condition is encountered: Pₜ = f(Rₜ, Mₜ) The preparation cascade consists of coordinated physiological and computational changes such as: - hormone release - autonomic activation - attention allocation - motor preparation - prediction updates These changes occur before or during action. No separate explanatory entity is introduced. --- ## Feeling This framework proposes: Feeling = Pₜ Feeling is not something produced by the preparation cascade. Feeling is the preparation cascade itself. There is no additional hidden phenomenon riding on top of the process. --- ## Internal Replay External stimulation is unnecessary. A remembered event can reactivate the same preparation machinery. If: Rₜ = internal r
Descripción para Zenodo (Español) Este trabajo introduce Functional Qualia Encoding (FQE), un marco teórico innovador que formaliza la experiencia subjetiva (qualia) no como un misterio ontológico, sino como una función de compresión de datos eficiente. Integrando principios de la termodinámica de no-equilibrio, inferencia activa y los Axiomas SER de Coherencia Emergente, proponemos que las emociones humanas pueden traducirse a ecuaciones de estado cuantificables (que vinculan variables fisiológicas, predictivas y relacionales). A través de cinco casos piloto —incluyendo "mariposas en el estómago", "saudade" y "vértigo existencial"— se demuestra cómo modelar matemáticamente la subjetividad. El objetivo final no es crear máquinas que "sientan", sino desarrollar una IA Ética y Relacional capaz de inferir y respetar la coherencia interna del usuario mediante una comprensión funcional, y no simulada, del afecto humano. Description for Zenodo (English) This paper introduces Functional Qualia Encoding (FQE), an innovative theoretical framework that formalizes subjective experience (qualia) not as an ontological mystery, but as an efficient data compression function. Integrating principles from nonequilibrium thermodynamics, active inference, and the SER Axioms of Emergent Coherence, we propose that human emotions can be translated into quantifiable state equations (linking physiological, predictive, and relational variables). Through five pilot cases—including "butterflies in the s
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.