Proteins run faster on nonreduced SDS-PAGE gels due to retained compact structures.
the verdict
CONTESTED
contested - evenly split
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
1 source for · 1 against
The evidence contains conflicting findings regarding the migration speed of proteins on nonreduced SDS-PAGE gels; one study reports faster migration for certain unreduced compact proteins, while another observes larger apparent molecular weights (slower migration) for unreduced antibodies.
Intracellular modifications of rat alpha 1 inhibitor3. Formation of disulphides, internal thiolester and sulphation. alpha 1 Inhibitor3 (alpha 1I3) is a monomeric protease inhibitor of about 190 kDa which is secreted by rodent hepatocytes. We have studied intracellular modifications of this protein in [35]methionine-labelled rat hepatocytes by pulse/chase experiments followed by immunoprecipitation and gel electrophoresis under reducing and nonreducing conditions. Directly after the pulse, most of the unreduced alpha 1I3 migrated faster than the reduced form, indicating that disulphide bridges are formed during or shortly after synthesis yielding a compact structure. With increasing chase time however, an increasing portion of the unreduced alpha 1I3 migrated with a mobility lower than that of the reduced protein, half-maximal conversion occurring after about 10 min. This finding suggests that alpha 1I3 undergoes a conformational change in the endoplasmic reticulum, possibly becoming more elongated. During 10-30 min of chase, the protein acquired the capacity to undergo autolytic cleavage upon heating, a property due to the existence of an internal thiolester bond [Howard, J.
Monoclonal antibodies are very important in modern therapeutics and constitute a substantial percentage of newly approved drugs. Every therapeutic monoclonal antibody must be analyzed for structural and functional integrity, and all protein heterogeneities need to be identified and quantified. The conformational stabilities of the monoclonal antibodies are also important for antibody storage and handling stabilities. One of the first and simplest of the structural analysis techniques utilized is SDS-PAGE, which can be performed both with and without prior reduction to break disulfide bonds. This permits sizing of both heavy and light chains in the reduced condition, and sizing of the intact antibody and any disulfide aggregates in the non-reduced condition. Analyzing our human anti-cocaine monoclonal antibody, we noted unexpectedly larger apparent molecular weights and apparent protein size heterogeneities using non-reducing SDS-PAGE. These apparent molecular weight heterogeneities are not consistent with other analysis techniques. Heterogeneities were noted using several heating and pre-electrophoretic sample preparation protocols, and are modified by the inclusion of small concentrations of certain alcohols such as propanol and butanol. All of these unexpected results were also observed for a commercial human IgG1 antibody, suggesting that these observations are applicable to IgGs in general. Thus, careful attention must be paid to the interpretation of non-reducing SDS-PAGE results for IgGs. It is hypothesized that differential thermal unfolding of the Fab, CH2 and CH3 domains of the IgGs in SDS give rise to the stable, discreet bands observed using different heating protocols prior to non-reducing SDS-PAGE.