Planetary geologists use specific instruments to detect subsurface oceans on Titan and Europa.
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
Scientific literature and reviews report that planetary missions use specialized instruments such as ice-penetrating radar and electromagnetic sounding to probe the interior structure of icy moons and identify subsurface oceans.
We present the state of the art on the study of surfaces and tenuous atmospheres of the icy Galilean satellites Ganymede, Europa and Callisto, from past and ongoing space exploration conducted with several spacecraft to recent telescopic observations, and we show how the ESA JUICE mission plans to explore these surfaces and atmospheres in detail with its scientific payload. The surface geology of the moons is the main evidence of their evolution and reflects the internal heating provided by tidal interactions. Surface composition is the result of endogenous and exogenous processes, with the former providing valuable information about the potential composition of shallow subsurface liquid pockets, possibly connected to deeper oceans. Finally, the icy Galilean moons have tenuous atmospheres that arise from charged particle sputtering affecting their surfaces. In the case of Europa, plumes of water vapour have also been reported, whose phenomenology at present is poorly understood and requires future close exploration. In the three main sections of the article, we discuss these topics, highlighting the key scientific objectives and investigations to be achieved by JUICE. Based on a recent predicted trajectory, we also show potential coverage maps and other examples of reference measurements. The scientific discussion and observation planning presented here are the outcome of the JUICE Working Group 2 (WG2): "<i>Surfaces and Near-surface Exospheres of the Satellites, dust and rings</i>".
Surface composition is the result of endogenous and exogenous processes, with the former providing valuable information about the potential composition of shallow subsurface liquid pockets, possibly connected to deeper oceans. Finally, the icy
As cryovolcanic eruptions might deliver materials from the interior (e.g., from subsurface oceans) to the surface, they would represent direct evidence for interior-surface exchange processes and, therefore, would make potential records of habitable environments (e.g., Kargel et al. 2000 ) accessible for remote sensing observations and possible future in situ analysis. Nevertheless, it should be noted that a direct ascent of ocean water to the surface of Europa is unlikely due to the very high pressures that would be required (Manga and Wang 2007 ), and shallow subsurface sources may be more likely (Gaidos and Nimmo 2000 ).
While Galileo/NIMS data could not safely detect CO 2 at Europa mostly due to the coarse spectral resolution combined with very low SNR longward of 2.7 μm, Trumbo and Brown ( 2023 ) mapped the regional distribution of CO 2 on Europa using observations obtained with JWST/NIRSpec, finding an unusual double-minima CO 2 feature concentrated at low latitudes in Tara Regio (10°S, 75°W), a young chaos terrain, which could indicate an internal carbon source, possibly the internal ocean. Based on the same dataset, Villanueva et al. ( 2023 ) also identified this CO 2 -rich feature and measured its 12 C/ 13 C isotope ratio, confirming an internal origin.
Connections Between Surface and Subsurface Processes The purpose of a combination of data from several remote sensing instruments, for specific regions of interest on the icy Galilean satellites, is to return a three-dimensional view of those regions, impossible to achieve from individual datasets. In the case of Europa and Ganymede, this data fusion could reveal locations where the exchange of liquid material between the shallow subsurface and the surface was more frequent and intense in the past. The potential deriving from such a multidisciplinary analysis is remarkable (e.g. Tosi et al. 2023 ).
The RIME ice penetrating radar is the key instrument to characterise the near-subsurface of the ice crust, detecting subsurface horizons and structures with differing dielectric constants up to a depth of a few km. RIME will provide constraints on the distribution and emplacement of subsurface materials having contrasting dielectric constants, which will be key to understanding the formation of various surface features. Combined with surface composition as derived by MAJIS and UVS, this could confirm recent activity and the possible presence of pockets of liquid water on Europa essential to habitability.
The search for liquid water being related to young surfaces (Collins and Nimmo 2009 ), RIME, in conjunction with other remote sensing instruments (JANUS, MAJIS, UVS, SWI), will determine the location of active sites and their relationship to subsurface water by detecting possible water interfaces and provide information about the rate of material exchange between the surface and the ocean as a function of the ice thickness (EB.1, EB.2, EB.3). At Callisto, RIME will characterise the upper kilometres of the ice shell (CA.1), determine the composition of the non-ice material (CB.2) and search for past and potentially recent activity (CC.1, CC.3).
In addition to broad atmospheric studies by the in situ and remote sensing instruments discussed above, other JUICE instruments will contribute to more specific atmospheric science goals. RPWI will measure the mass and size distribution of charged dust particles within the satellite exospheres (GE.2c, EC.1c, CB.1f, CB.2f), studying how they are accelerated towards the surface where they contribute to sputtering of material into the exospheres. JMAG may detect magnetic field perturbations due to atmospheric inhomogeneities: for example, models by Blöcker et al.
Since SWI targets low excitation rotation lines it may also be able to detect transient sources more directly from observations at the terminator in nadir or limb geometry, and even over the cold night-time surface over the un-illuminated hemisphere. The possibility that ongoing plume activity could transport material from Europa’s subsurface, or from water reservoirs contained in the ice layer, creates an unprecedented opportunity to sample Europa’s subsurface environment and investigate its habitability.
Electromagnetic (EM) sounding of planetary bodies other than the Earth was first possible on the Moon, but has since been used to probe interior structure of planets and moons throughout the solar system. This emergence has been facilitated by the growing availability of mission data and associated improved understanding of planetary magnetic field environments. In this review, I outline the general principles of EM induction, with particular emphasis on planetary specific assumptions and aspects that have to be considered in non-terrestrial environments, including limited or incomplete datasets. I review magnetic field mission data from past and ongoing space missions that can support EM investigations. The availability and quality of such data determine the scope and depth of investigations, ranging from characterizing most interior layers to identifying subsurface oceans. Looking ahead, upcoming missions will facilitate a better characterization of planetary bodies, which will contribute to addressing most fundamental questions, including the possibility of oceans and potential for life within the Jovian system.
In this review, I outline the general principles of EM induction, with particular emphasis on planetary specific assumptions and aspects that have to be considered in non-terrestrial environments, including limited or incomplete datasets. I review magnetic field mission data from past and ongoing space missions that can support EM investigations. The availability and quality of such data determine the scope and depth of investigations, ranging from characterizing most interior layers to identifying subsurface oceans.
Unknowns range from large-scale structure and composition of planetary bodies, e.g., the presence of a core, to more specific questions such as the presence of an ocean or interior abundance of volatiles. Generally, the abundance of volatiles in our solar system is of great importance. In the case of Mars or Venus, it is unclear what happened to the water that once existed; did it escape to space or is it captured in the crust? What plays a role in the emergence of plate tectonics?
Because no combined electric and magnetic field measurements have enabled MT studies so far, the focus for inner solar system bodies is on (a) understanding and approximating the inducing field, i.e., the external magnetic field environment, or (b) the use of an additional spacecraft which measures the inducing field concurrently (Grimm and Delory 2012 ). For outer solar system bodies, the sparsity of data typically limits EM studies to testing specific hypotheses, such as the existence of a highly conductive layer, as expected for a subsurface ocean. Generally, the penetration depth of electromagnetic waves depends on the period, T, and the material they propagate through.
As the first mission in orbit around Jupiter, Galileo provided evidence of induction signals attributed to subsurface oceans of the Galilean moons Io, Europa, Callisto, and Ganymede (Kivelson et al. 1992 ). After its interplanetary cruise, Galileo entered three mission phases, the primary tour (1995–1998), the Galileo Europa Mission (1998–2000), and finally, the Galileo Millenium Mission (2000–2003), all focused on studying Jupiter and its moons with a focus on Europa in the second mission phase (Fig. 5 ). Fig.
Compared to Apollo-era studies, the use of higher precision instruments, long-duration time series, and advanced computational techniques offers a unique opportunity to revisit outstanding questions with significantly improved accuracy and resolution. Such questions include the presence of a partially molten basal layer (Grimm and Delory 2012 ) or possible compositional heterogeneity within the lunar interior, possibly suggesting incomplete magma ocean mixing and a complex thermal evolution.
2000 ), underlining the importance of EM sounding in exploring planetary bodies. A renewed focus on those bodies is especially timely due to upcoming missions, such as JUICE and Europa Clipper, that will provide critical new datasets to further explore the presence and properties of these hypothesized oceans. Europa’s distinctly characteristic surface shows cracks across an 80–170 km thick icy surface. Multiple lines of evidence support the idea that this ice layer overlies an ocean (Pappalardo et al. 1999 ). Callisto and Ganymede might also host a subsurface ocean, although their internal structures remain more uncertain and continue to be debated (Khurana et al. 1998 ).
( 1939 ) and Srivastava ( 1966 ), then summarized in the context of planetary-scale problems (Parkinson 1983 ) was proposed by Zimmer et al. ( 2000 ); this study remains the basis for the literature in the field. Generally, a perfectly conducting ocean would induce the largest response, with an amplitude equal to the inducing field. In this case, the ocean would fully shield the interior from
A self-consistent induction model including a three-layer shell, comprising a core, mantle, and subsurface ocean, surrounded by an insulating crust and plasma currents, provided better constraints on Europa’s interior (Schilling et al. 2007 , 2008 ). This model supported ocean conductivities of at least 0.25 S/m of 100 km thickness. These results are consistent with the presence of a liquid saline ocean, effectively ruling out scenarios involving either a frozen or soft ice layer. While all previous work relied on the synodic rotation period, Seufert et al.
These geysers are believed to originate from a subsurface ocean beneath Enceladus’ icy crust. The ocean, likely salty and in contact with the moon’s rocky core, may contain hydrothermal vents, providing a potential habitat for life. The interaction between the ocean and the core could supply the necessary chemical ingredients and energy sources to support microbial life Ermakov et al. ( 2021 ). Titan, Saturn’s largest moon, also presents strong evidence for a subsurface ocean (e.g., Sohl et al. 2003 ).
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.