trustme.bro/r/…
✓ checked
trust me, bro:
here is the receipt.
the claim
PCl5 exists as an ionic solid in the solid state
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
9 sources for · 0 against

Multiple chemical references and peer-reviewed sources establish that phosphorus pentachloride (PCl5) exists in the solid state as an ionic compound composed of [PCl4]+ and [PCl6]− ions.

Evidence for · 9
1973 · cited by 14
Abstract Chlorine-35 nuclear quadrupole resonance frequencies in the ionic crystal PCl4+·PCl6− were redetermined. Ten resonance lines were found and their temperature dependences were measured below the second order phase transition point at 102 K. The splitting Δvi in the resonance lines in the low temperature phase showed a similar temperature dependence as the order parameter. This was accounted for by a librational soft mode theory based on an anharmonic coupling between molecular or ionic librational modes in the crystal.
See more details
The analysis

rails:sufficiency:supported:for=8+0p:against=0+0p | v55:sufficiency

More for · 8
1979 · cited by 9
It is suggested that the PCl6− ion should ionize to PCl4+ and 2Cl− in the solid under pressure, and evidence has been sought by measuring the phase diagram of phosphorus pentachloride, which has the constitution PCl4+PCl6−. Two new phases were discovered, one of which is wholly metastable relative to the ordinary phase.
1979 · cited by 9
The Raman spectrum of phosphorus pentachloride III, which is obtained by squeezing the ordinary phase II to a few kilobars (see preceding paper), has been recorded at ∼100 K and zero pressure. The ratio of the integrated intensities of the PCl4+ and PCl6− ions is much smaller in phase III than in phase II, showing that the ionization PCl6−→PCl4++2Cl− occurs in the solid at the transition. It appears to be the first example of a pressure-induced ionizing dissociation in a solid. Phase III is similar to, but apparently not identical with, a phase obtained by subliming phase II and condensing the vapor at, apparently, room temperature. The implications of this transformation for the synthesis of inorganic compounds is briefly discussed.
cited by 0
chloride exists as neutral POCl3 molecules in the solid, liquid and gas states. This is unlike phosphorus pentachloride which exists as neutral PCl5 molecules Phosphoryl chloride (commonly called phosphorus oxychloride) is a colourless liquid with the formula POCl3. It hydrolyses in moist air releasing phosphoric acid and fumes of hydrogen chloride. It is manufactured industrially on a large scale from phosphorus trichloride and oxygen or phosphorus pentoxide. It is mainly used to make phosphate esters. Phosphoryl chloride exists as neutral POCl3 molecules in the solid, liquid and gas states. This is unlike phosphorus pentachloride which exists as neutral PCl5 molecules in the gas and liquid states but adopts the ionic form [PCl4]+[PCl6]− (tetrachlorophosphonium hexachlorophosphate(V)) in the solid state. The average bond lengths in the crystal structure of POCl3 are 1.98 Å for P–Cl and 1.46 Å for P=O.
2001 · cited by 0
[10026-13-8] Cl5P (MW 208.22) InChI = 1S/Cl5P/c1-6(2,3,4)5 InChIKey = UHZYTMXLRWXGPK-UHFFFAOYSA-N (chlorination of alcohols,2 carboxylic acids,3 amides,4 aldehydes, ketones, and enols; Bischler–Napieralski synthesis of 3,4-dihydroisoquinolines;5 Beckmann rearrangement of oximes6) Alternate Name: phosphorus pentachloride. Physical Data: mp 179–181 °C (sublimes); d 1.6 g cm−3. Solubility: sol CS2, CCl4. Typical solvents for reactions which use PCl5 are CCl4, CHCl3, CH2Cl2, hexane, decane, benzene, toluene, and diethyl ether. Form Supplied in: white to pale yellow solid; widely available. In the solid state, PCl5 exists in the ionic form, [PCl4]+ [PCl6]−. Purification: by vacuum sublimation.7 Handling, Storage, and Precautions: reacts with moisture to liberate hydrochloric acid and phosphoric acids. It is extremely corrosive to the skin, eyes, and mucous membranes. It should be stored in a dry area in containers impervious to moisture and resistant to corrosion. Laboratory quantities may be stored in polyethylene bags placed within glass containers. This reagent should be used in a fume hood.
cited by 0
trigonal bipyramidal structure persists in nonpolar solvents, such as CS2 and CCl4. In the solid state PCl5 is an ionic compound called tetrachlorophosphonium Phosphorus pentachloride is the chemical compound with the formula PCl5. It is one of the most important phosphorus chlorides/oxychlorides, others being PCl3 and POCl3. PCl5 finds use as a chlorinating reagent. It is a colourless, water-sensitive solid, although commercial samples can be yellowish and contaminated with hydrogen chloride. PCl3 +…
cited by 0
The liquid does not conduct electricity because of the lack of ions or mobile electrons. Phosphorus(III) chloride reacts violently with water to generate phosphorous acid, H3PO3, and hydrogen chloride fumes (or a solution containing hydrochloric acid in excess of water): \[ PCl_3 + 3H_2O \rightarrow H_3PO_3 + 3HCl \nonumber \] Phosphorus(V) chloride (PCl5) Phosphorus(V) chloride is structurally more complicated than phosphorus(III) chloride. At room temperature, it forms a white solid which sublimes at 163°C. Increasing the temperature beyond its sublimation point dissociates (divides reversibly) more the phosphorus(V) chloride into phosphorus(III) chloride and chlorine: \[ PCl_5 \rightleftharpoons PCl_3 + Cl_2 \nonumber \] Phosphorus(V) chloride is an ionic solid. The formation of the ions involves two molecules of PCl5. A chloride ion transfers from one of the original molecules to the other, leaving a positive ion, [PCl4]+, and a negative ion, [PCl6]-. At 163°C, the phosphorus(V) chloride converts to a molecular form containing PCl5 molecules. Because only van der Waals dispersion forces exist between these molecules, the species vaporizes.
2002 · cited by 0
Die Pentahalogene der 5. Hauptgruppe zeigen einen interessanten strukturellen Verlauf. Das seit knapp 200 Jahren bekannte PCl5 liegt im festen Zustand als Ionenpaar vor [PCl4+][PCl6-]. Für SbCl5 wurde zusätzlich zu der bekannten monomeren trigonal bipyramidalen Kristallstruktur, eine dimere Anordnung vorhergesagt. Dieses konnte bestätigt werden. Antimonpentachlorid wandelt sich ab -55°C in die dimere Form um. Antimon ist das erste Element der fünften Hauptgruppe, bei dem die dimere Struktur des Pentahalogenids durch Kristallstrukturanalyse nachgewiesen werden konnte. Die Frage, ob das AsCl5 das Zwischenglied von ionischer zur dimerer Struktur bildet, konnte ebenfalls beantwortet werden. Obwohl es ab -30°C zur Zersetzung von AsCl5 in AsCl3 und Cl2 kommt, gelang es, Einkristalle zu erhalten und die Struktur der Verbindung durch Röntgenbeugung bei tiefen Temperaturen aufzuklären. AsCl5 bildet eine trigonale Bipyra-mide, mit drei kürzeren äquatorialen und zwei längeren axialen Bindungen. Ein Vergleich der Schichtstrukturen von Antimonpentachlorid und Arsenpentachlorid zeigt, daß die SbCl5 - Moleküle eine hexagonal dichteste Kugelpackung bilden, während die AsCl5 -Moleküle kubisch innenzentriert kristallisieren. Es wurden zwei Verbindungen erhalten, welche durch Hydrolyse von AsCl5 entstanden sind. Dies sind Salze, die das oktaedrische AsCl6¯- Ion enthalten. Bei der einen Verbindung tritt AsOCl3 als Monomer auf mit As-O - Doppelbindung und ist solvatisiert von H5O2+AsCl6¯. Die and
2008 · cited by 0
exists in the solid as an array of PCl} and PCI; ions, whereas in the gas phase it exists as discrete … negative in the —z hemisphere; further, cos (¢) is positive in the +x hemisphere, and negative in the —x. … the other electron in the 2p, the two electrons in the 2s and the two electrons in the 1s. If we go to an
Everything we examined (9) — 8 independent sources
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.
  1. Phosphoryl chloridereferencesame source L1no side taken
  2. Phosphorus(V) Chloridepeer-reviewedno side taken
  3. Phosphorus pentachloridereferencesame source L1no side taken
  4. Phase Transition in the Ionic Modification of Phosphorus Pentachloride, [PCl4][PCl6]. Chlorine Nuclear Quadrupole Resonance Studypeer-reviewedno side taken
  5. LibreTexts: Chlorides of Period 3 Elementsreferenceno side taken
  6. The ionization of PCl6− in the solid state under pressure. I. Phase diagram of phosphorus pentachloridepeer-reviewedno side taken
  7. The ionization of PCl6− in the solid state under pressure. II. Raman spectrum of phosphorus pentachloride IIIpeer-reviewedno side taken
  8. Pentahalogenide und Oxidhalogenide der Elemente der fünften Hauptgruppepeer-reviewedno side taken
  9. Chemical structure and reactivity : an integrated approachreferenceno side taken
This receipt carries no identity, shared or not. Sharing publishes your connection to it, not your data.
Check your own claim
Challenge the receipt
trust me, bro: win the argument, pass the class, survive peer review.
This receipt is an automated verdict against our published method · not an opinion about any author or publication.
Terms · Privacy · How verdicts work · Dispute this receipt