Oxygen existed primarily in mineral forms before the Great Oxygenation Event
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
8 sources for · 0 against
Geological and geochemical evidence establishes that Earth's early atmosphere and oceans were largely anoxic prior to the Great Oxygenation Event, with oxygen sequestered primarily in reduced mineral forms like pyrite and uraninite.
The last 3.85 Gyr of Earth history have been divided into five stages. During stage 1 (3.85-2.45 Gyr ago (Ga)) the atmosphere was largely or entirely anoxic, as were the oceans, with the possible exception of oxygen oases in the shallow oceans. During stage 2 (2.45-1.85 Ga) atmospheric oxygen levels rose to values estimated to have been between 0.02 and 0.04 atm. The shallow oceans became mildly oxygenated, while the deep oceans continued anoxic. Stage 3 (1.85-0.85 Ga) was apparently rather 'boring'. Atmospheric oxygen levels did not change significantly. Most of the surface oceans were mildly oxygenated, as were the deep oceans. Stage 4 (0.85-0.54 Ga) saw a rise in atmospheric oxygen to values not much less than 0.2 atm. The shallow oceans followed suit, but the deep oceans were anoxic, at least during the intense Neoproterozoic ice ages. Atmospheric oxygen levels during stage 5 (0.54 Ga-present) probably rose to a maximum value of ca 0.3 atm during the Carboniferous before returning to its present value. The shallow oceans were oxygenated, while the oxygenation of the deep oceans fluctuated considerably, perhaps on rather geologically short time-scales.
The rapid increase of carbon dioxide concentration in Earth's modern atmosphere is a matter of major concern. But for the atmosphere of roughly two-and-half billion years ago, interest centres on a different gas: free oxygen (O2) spawned by early biological production. The initial increase of O2 in the atmosphere, its delayed build-up in the ocean, its increase to near-modern levels in the sea and air two billion years later, and its cause-and-effect relationship with life are among the most compelling stories in Earth's history.
Constraining oxygen levels in the early Precambrian surface
ocean has been a longstanding goal, but efforts have been challenged by
the availability of suitable proxies. Here we present a novel approach,
iodine geochemistry, which broadens our perspective by providing constraints
on shallow, carbonate-dominated marine settings. Iodate (IO 3 – )
persists exclusively in oxic waters and is the sole iodine species incorporated
into carbonate minerals, allowing iodine-to-calcium ratios
(I/Ca) in shallow carbonates to be used as a paleoredox indicator. Our
data from a series of Mesoarchean through Paleoproterozoic carbonates
deposited under shallow-marine conditions reveal a progressive
surface ocean oxygenation in the early Paleoproterozoic. These data
seem to indicate that a largely anoxic surface ocean extended throughout
the Archean until the Great Oxidation Event (GOE) at ca. 2.4 Ga,
implying that previous inferences of pre-GOE oxygen production may
reflect oxygen oases, transient oxidation events, or oxygen levels below
those required for IO 3 – accumulation. The data suggest formation and
persistence of IO 3 – and, consequently, surface ocean oxygen concentrations
of at least 1 μM during the GOE. Following the initial rise of oxygen,
carbonate-associated iodine in globally extensive carbonate units
deposited during the Lomagundi positive carbon isotope excursion at
ca. 2.22–2.1 Ga suggests a widespread aerobic iodine cycle beyond that
operating prior to the event, synchronous with high relative rates of
organic carbon burial and apparent expansion of oxidative conditions.
The origin of complex life and the evolution of terrestrial ecosystems are fundamental aspects of the natural history on Earth. Here, we present evidence for a protracted stabilization of the Earth's ozone layer. The destruction of atmospheric ozone today is inherently linked to the cycling of marine and atmospheric iodine. Supported by multiple independent lines of geological evidence and examined through an iodine mass balance model, we find that elevated marine iodide content prevailed through most of Earth's history. Since the rise of oxygen ~2.4 billion years ago, high marine iodide concentrations would have led to significant inorganic iodine emissions to the atmosphere, facilitating catalytic ozone destruction and resulting in atmospheric ozone instability with periodic or persistently lower ozone levels. At a global scale, unstable and low ozone levels likely persisted for about two billion years until the early Phanerozoic, roughly 0.5 billion years ago. The delayed stabilization of the Earth's ozone layer holds significant implications for the tempo and direction of the evolution of life, in particular life on land.
The Great Oxidation Event (GOE) or Great Oxygenation Event, also called the Oxygen Catastrophe, Oxygen Revolution, Oxygen Crisis, or Oxygen Holocaust
The Great Oxidation Event (GOE) or Great Oxygenation Event, also called the Oxygen Catastrophe, Oxygen Revolution, Oxygen Crisis, or Oxygen Holocaust, was a time interval during the Earth's Paleoproterozoic era when the Earth's atmosphere and shallow seas first experienced a rise in the concentration of free oxygen. This began approximately 2.46–2.426 billion years ago (Ga) during the Siderian per
The composition of the Earth's earliest atmosphere is not known with certainty. However, the bulk was likely nitrogen N2, and carbon dioxide CO2, which are also the predominant nitrogen- and carbon-bearing gases produced by modern volcanism. These are relatively inert gases. Oxygen in its O2 form, meanwhile, was present in the atmosphere at just 0.001% of recent atmospheric levels.
The Sun shone at about 70% of its modern brightness 4 billion years ago, but there is strong evidence that liquid water existed on Earth at the time. A warm Earth, in spite of a faint Sun, is known as the faint young Sun paradox. Either CO2 levels were much higher at the time, providing enough of a greenhouse effect to warm the Earth, or other greenhouse gases were present. The most likely such gas is methane, CH4, which is a powerful greenhouse gas and was produced by early forms of life known as methanogens. Scientists continue to research how the Earth was warmed before life arose.
An atmosphere of N2 and CO2 with trace amounts of H2O, CH4, carbon monoxide (CO), and hydrogen (H2) is described as a weakly reducing atmosphere. Such an atmosphere contains practically no oxygen. The modern atmosphere contains abundant oxygen (nearly 21%), making it an oxidizing atmosphere. The rise in oxygen is attributed to photosynthesis by cyanobacteria, which are thought to have evolved as early as 3.5 billion years ago.
The scientific understanding of when an
The composition of the Earth's earliest atmosphere is not known with certainty. However, the bulk was likely nitrogen N2, and carbon dioxide CO2, which are also the predominant nitrogen- and carbon-bearing gases produced by modern volcanism. These are relatively inert gases. Oxygen in its O2 form, meanwhile, was present in the atmosphere at just 0.001% of recent atmospheric levels.
The Sun shone at about 70% of its modern brightness 4 billion years ago, but there is strong evidence that liquid water existed on Earth at the time. A warm Earth, in spite of a faint Sun, is known as the faint young Sun paradox. Either CO2 levels were much higher at the time, providing enough of a greenhouse effect to warm the Earth, or other greenhouse gases were present. The most likely such gas is methane, CH4, which is a powerful greenhouse gas and was produced by early forms of life known as methanogens. Scientists continue to research how the Earth was warmed before life arose.
An atmosphere of N2 and CO2 with trace amounts of H2O, CH4, carbon monoxide (CO), and hydrogen (H2) is described as a weakly reducing atmosphere. Such an atmosphere contains practically no oxygen. The modern atmosphere contains abundant oxygen (nearly 21%), making it an oxidizing atmosphere. The rise in oxygen is attributed to photosynthesis by cyanobacteria, which are thought to have evolved as early as 3.5 billion years ago.
The scientific understanding of when and how the Earth's atmosphere changed from a weakly reducing to a strongly oxidizing atmosphere largely began with the work of the American geologist Preston Cloud in the 1970s. Cloud observed that detrital sediments older than about 2 billion years contained grains of pyrite, uraninite, and siderite, all minerals containing reduced forms of iron or uranium that are not found in younger sediments because they are rapidly oxidized in an oxidizing atmosphere. He further observed that continental red beds, which get their color from the oxidized (ferric) mineral hematite, began to appear in the geological record at about this time. Banded iron formation largely disappears from the geological record at 1.85 Ga, after peaking at about 2.5 Ga. Banded iron formation can form only when abundant dissolved ferrous iron is transported into depositional basins, and an oxygenated ocean blocks such transport by oxidizing the iron to form insoluble ferric iron compounds. The end of the deposition of banded iron formation at 1.85 Ga is therefore interpreted as marking the oxygenation of the deep ocean. Heinrich Holland further elaborated these ideas through the 1980s, placing the main time interval of oxygenation between 2.2 and 1.9 Ga.
Constraining the onset of atmospheric oxygenation has proven particularly challenging for geologists and geochemists. While there is a widespread consensus that initial oxygenation of the atmosphere happened sometime during the first half of the Paleoproterozoic, there is disagreement on the exact timing of this event. Scientific publications between 2016–2022 have differed in the inferred timing of the onset of atmospheric oxygenation by approximately 500 million years; estimates of 2.7 Ga, 2.501–2.434 Ga 2.501–2.225 Ga, 2.460–2.426 Ga, 2.430 Ga, 2.33 Ga, and 2.3 Ga have been given. Factors limiting calculations include an incomplete sedimentary record for the Paleoproterozoic (e.g., because of subduction and metamorphism), uncertainties in depositional ages for many ancient sedimentary units, and uncertainties related to the interpretation of different geological/geochemical proxies. While the effects of an incomplete geological record have been discussed and quantified in the field of paleontology for several decades, particularly with respect to the evolution and extinction of organisms (the Signor–Lipps effect), this is rarely quantified when considering geochemical records and may therefore lead to uncertainties for scientists studying the timing of atmospheric oxygenation.
The primitive Earth was characterized by an oxygen-poor ocean–atmosphere system, and experienced a significant increase in oxygen concentrations during the Great Oxidation Event (GOE) ca 2.45 Ga. This event is generally believed to be linked in some way to oxygenic photosynthesis by bacteria. However, it is becoming commonly accepted that “whiffs” of oxygen existed before the GOE. To shed new light on this emerging paradigm, here we present molybdenum (Mo) isotopic data for modern stromatolites from Bacalar lagoon, Mexico, and ancient stromatolites from Archean sediments deposited ca. 2.52 Ga (Ghaap Group, South Africa), 2.8 Ga (Steep Rock, Canada), and 2.96 Ga (Red Lake, Canada). Modern samples record a molybdenum isotopic signature that appears related to the water from which they grew, supporting the idea that the molybdenum isotopic composition of carbonates is a robust proxy for examining paleo-redox conditions of environments where carbonates were precipitated. Ancient stromatolites reveal evidence for oxygen in the environment at 2.96 Ga at 2.8 Ga, while stromatolites from the Ghaap Group (2.52 Ga) appear to have grown under poorly-oxygenated conditions. My data suggests that oxygenic photosynthesis existed yet at least 0.61 Ga before the rise of atmospheric oxygen. Moreover, the consistent signal for oxygen in the environment at this time could be indicative of a constant period of mild oxygenation, rather than local oases as previously proposed.
The Earth has had a permanently oxic atmosphere only since the great oxygenation event (GOE) 2.3-2.4 billion years ago but recent geochemical research has revealed short periods of oxygen in the atmosphere up to a billion years earlier before the permanent oxygenation. If these "whiffs" of oxygen truly occurred, then oxygen-evolving (proto)cyanobacteria must have existed throughout the Archaean aeon. Trapping of oxygen by ferrous iron and other reduced substances present in Archaean oceans has often been suggested to explain why the oxygen content of the atmosphere remained negligible before the GOE although cyanobacteria produced oxygen. We tested this hypothesis by growing cyanobacteria in anaerobic high-CO2 atmosphere in a medium with a high concentration of ferrous iron. Microcystins are known to chelate iron, which prompted us also to test the effects of microcystins and nodularins on iron tolerance. The results show that all tested cyanobacteria, especially nitrogen-fixing species grown in the absence of nitrate, and irrespective of the ability to produce cyanotoxins, were iron sensitive in aerobic conditions but tolerated high concentrations of iron in anaerobicity. This result suggests that current cyanobacteria would have tolerated the high-iron content of Archaean oceans. However, only 1 % of the oxygen produced by the cyanobacterial culture was trapped by iron, suggesting that large-scale cyanobacterial photosynthesis would have oxygenated the atmosphere even if cy
an oxygen-containing atmosphere began to develop, apparently due to a billion years of cyanobacterial photosynthesis (known as the Great Oxygenation Event)
The atmosphere of Earth consists of a layer of mixed gas (commonly referred to as air) that is retained by gravity, surrounding the Earth's surface. It contains variable quantities of suspended aerosols and particulates that create weather features such as clouds and hazes. The atmosphere serves as a protective buffer between the Earth's surface and outer space. It shields the surface from most me
The…
Everything we examined (8) — 7 independent sources
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.