trustme.bro/r/…
✓ checked
trust me, bro:
here is the receipt.
the claim
Marbles do not naturally arrange into a crystal due to surface friction and geometric frustration
the verdict
INSUFFICIENT LEANING
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
4 sources for · 0 against

Retrieved literature touches upon the suppression of crystallization in particle packings and the general behavior of frictional spheres, but provides only partial support regarding the specific combination of surface friction and geometric frustration as the sole causes for marbles failing to crystallize.

Evidence for · 4
2017 · cited by 38
Uncovering grain-scale mechanisms that underlie the disorder-order transition in assemblies of dissipative, athermal particles is a fundamental problem with technological relevance. To date, the study of granular crystallization has mainly focussed on the symmetry of crystalline patterns while their emergence and growth from irregular clusters of grains remains largely unexplored. Here crystallization of three-dimensional packings of frictional spheres is studied at the grain-scale using X-ray tomography and persistent homology. The latter produces a map of the topological configurations of grains within static partially crystallized packings. Using numerical simulations, we show that similar maps are measured dynamically during the melting of a perfect crystal. This map encodes new information on the formation process of tetrahedral and octahedral pores, the building blocks of perfect crystals. Four key formation mechanisms of these pores reproduce the main changes of the map during crystallization and provide continuous deformation pathways representative of the crystallization dynamics.
See more details
The analysis

rails:sufficiency:partial_only:for=0+3p:against=0+0p | v55:multi_partial_one_side:lean=lean_partial:for:one_sided

More for · 3
cited by 0
The role of fivefold symmetry in suppressing crystallization | Nature Communications ### Subjects - Phase transitions and critical phenomena - Self-assembly - Statistical mechanics ## Abstract Although long assumed to have an important role in the suppression of crystallization and the development of glassformers, the effect of local fivefold symmetry has never been directly tested. Here we consider whether such suppression of crystallization has a kinetic or thermodynamic nature and investigate its mechanism. We introduce a model in which the degree of fivefold symmetry can be tuned by favouring arrangements of particles in pentagonal bipyramids. We thus show that fivefold symmetry has both kinetic and thermodynamic effects on the mechanism of crystallization to a face-centred cubic crystal. Our results suggest that the mechanism of crystallization suppression is related to the surface tension between fluid and crystal. Interestingly, the degree of fivefold symmetry has little effect on crystal growth rate, suggesting that growth may be only weakly coupled to fluid structure in hard sphere like systems. Upon increasing the fivefold symmetry, we find a first-order transition to
cited by 0
# Why don't marbles naturally arrange themselves like a crystal? - Tags: solid-state-physics, crystals - Score: 24 - Views: 8,880 - Answers: 8 - Asked by: user342326 (369 rep) - Asked on: Nov 25, 2018 - Last active: Nov 27, 2018 - License: CC BY-SA 4.0 --- ## Question Most solids are crystalline in nature because the energy released during the formation of ordered structure is more than that released during the formation of disordered structure such that the crystalline state is the lower energy state. So if we take different marbles in a box and shake it then shouldn't they arrange themselves in order to get to a low energy state? But we see they arrange in a disorderly way. Why do different phenomenon occur in these two cases? --- ## Answer 1 — Score: 33 - By: GiorgioP-DoomsdayClockIsAt-85 (42,332 rep) - Answered on: Nov 25, 2018 Interaction between marbles is very similar to the hard sphere (HS) interaction model i.e. a pair-wise potential energy which is zero if spheres do not overlap and $+\\infty$ elsewhere. Hard spheres are one of the first systems studied via computer simulation and one of the first big surprise was that by increasing pressure, they are able to cry
cited by 0
Identity crisis in alchemical space drives the entropic colloidal glass transition | Nature Communications ### Subjects ## Abstract A universally accepted explanation for why liquids sometimes vitrify rather than crystallize remains hotly pursued, despite the ubiquity of glass in our everyday lives, the utilization of the glass transition in innumerable modern technologies, and nearly a century of theoretical and experimental investigation. Among the most compelling hypothesized mechanisms underlying glass formation is the development in the fluid phase of local structures that somehow prevent crystallization. Here, we explore that mechanism in the case of hard particle glasses by examining the glass transition in an extended alchemical (here, shape) space; that is, a space where particle shape is treated as a thermodynamic variable. We investigate simple systems of hard polyhedra, with no interactions aside from volume exclusion, and show via Monte Carlo simulation that glass formation in these systems arises from a multiplicity of competing local motifs, each of which is prevalent in—and predictable from—nearby ordered structures in alchemical space. ### Emerging exotic compo
Everything we examined (4) — 3 independent sources
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.
  1. Pore configuration landscape of granular crystallization.peer-reviewedno side taken
  2. The role of fivefold symmetry in suppressing crystallization | Nature Communicationsreferencesame source L21no side taken
  3. Why don't marbles naturally arrange themselves like a crystal?referenceno side taken
  4. Identity crisis in alchemical space drives the entropic colloidal glass transition | Nature Communicationsreferencesame source L21no side taken
The paper trail · every fact has a biography
held for human review08 Aug 2026
This receipt carries no identity, shared or not. Sharing publishes your connection to it, not your data.
Check your own claim
Challenge the receipt
trust me, bro: win the argument, pass the class, survive peer review.
This receipt is an automated verdict against our published method · not an opinion about any author or publication.
Terms · Privacy · How verdicts work · Dispute this receipt