Maimonides significantly influenced the philosophy of Spinoza
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
6 sources for · 0 against
Scholarly literature and reference sources indicate that Maimonides's philosophical works and ideas significantly influenced Spinoza, despite areas of critical departure.
Spinoza is a severe critic of Maimonides and the whole medieval theistic tradition. Nevertheless, as recent philosophical scholarship has shown, Spinoza shares much with Maimonides in his own philosophical outlook. In this chapter I point to an important commonality in their respective views of the human good, namely the emphasis each places upon dispassion as a corollary of any deep understanding of God and/or nature.
training in philosophy . In contrast with Maimonides ’ account, Spinoza insists that the object of Scripture ... from Maimonides ’s view of human eudaimonia, Spinoza argues that the mind’s intellectual love of God is ... phrase—and Spinoza was clearly influenced by his reading of that British thinker—life in the state of nature ...
This chapter focuses on how Maimonides’ thought influenced Spinoza. The problem is that Maimonides’ philosophy is notoriously difficult to interpret. In the Introduction of the Guide to the Perplexed, he says that he will not put all of his thoughts on a given topic in one place and that he intends to contradict himself. The result is that Maimonides appears in the history of philosophy under several guises: Aristotelian and critic of Aristotle, rationalist and skeptic, defender of creation and defender of eternity, pious Jew and Jewish heretic. According to one account, the transition from one thinker to another is smooth; according to another account, it represents a radical break. After discussing both of these views, a third option is offered: that Spinoza had little patience with trying to decipher Maimonides’ inner thoughts and set out to put philosophy on a new and much clearer footing.
To these must be added certain portions of the Mishnah commentary, such as the “Eight Chapters,” the discussion on reward and punishment and immortality, the Jewish Creed, which have acquired fame as independent works. The influence of Moses ben Maimon is incalculable. “From Moses unto Moses there arose not one like Moses,” is the verdict of posterity. Maimonides was the great exponent of reason in faith and toleration in theology. One of the main services to European thought of the “Guide” was its independent criticism of some of Aristotle’s principles. His codification of the Talmud was equally appreciated in the study of the scholar and in practical life. Christian Europe owed much to Maimonides. Not only did his “Guide” influence scholasticism in general, but it was from his Code that the Church derived its medieval knowledge of the Synagogue. A complete bibliography will be found in Maimonides, by David Yellin and Israel Abrahams (London, 1903); the final chapter of that work gives a summary of the influence of Maimonides on Christian philosophers such as Aquinas, and Jewish such as Spinoza. The “Guide” has been translated into English by M.
analysis of the good is similar to Hobbes’s at Leviathan VI. Maimonides , another of Spinoza ’s influences ... 2017, “ Spinoza on the Association of the Affects and the Workings of the Human Mind,” in Spinoza ’s Ethics ... Carlisle, C., 2017, “ Spinoza ’s Acquiescentia,” Journal of the History of Philosophy , 55(2): 209–236. Carriero ...
fructification through the Japhetic spirit to produce philosophers such as Philo, Maimonides , and Spinoza . But philosophy is everywhere present when the natural, moral
Everything we examined (6) — 4 independent sources
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.