Human brains share highly similar structures, regional specializations, and functional organization.
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
5 sources for · 0 against
Neuroimaging literature and evolutionary frameworks confirm that human brains share highly similar large-scale structural networks, modular regional specializations, and functional organization across individuals.
Large-scale covariance of cortical thickness or volume in distributed brain regions has been consistently reported by human neuroimaging studies. The mechanism of this population covariance of regional cortical anatomy has been hypothetically related to synchronized maturational changes in anatomically connected neuronal populations. Brain regions that grow together, i.e., increase or decrease in volume at the same rate over the course of years in the same individual, are thus expected to demonstrate strong structural covariance or anatomical connectivity across individuals. To test this prediction, we used a structural MRI dataset on healthy young people (N = 108; aged 9–22 years at enrollment), comprising 3–6 longitudinal scans on each participant over 6–12 years of follow-up. At each of 360 regional nodes, and for each participant, we estimated the following: (1) the cortical thickness in the median scan and (2) the linear rate of change in cortical thickness over years of serial scanning. We constructed structural and maturational association matrices and networks from these measurements. Both structural and maturational networks shared similar global and nodal topological properties, as well as mesoscopic features including a modular community structure, a relatively small number of highly connected hub regions, and a bias toward short distance connections. Using resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging data on a subset of the sample (N = 32), we also demonstrated that functional connectivity and network organization was somewhat predictable by structural/maturational networks but demonstrated a stronger bias toward short distance connections and greater topological segregation. Brain structural covariance networks are likely to reflect synchronized developmental change in distributed cortical regions.
Gender differences in psychological processes have been of great interest in a variety of fields. While the majority of research in this area has focused on specific differences in relation to test performance, this study sought to determine the underlying neurofunctional differences observed during working memory, a pivotal cognitive process shown to be predictive of academic achievement and intelligence. Using the BrainMap database, we performed a meta-analysis and applied activation likelihood estimation to our search set. Our results demonstrate consistent working memory networks across genders, but also provide evidence for gender-specific networks whereby females consistently activate more limbic (e.g., amygdala and hippocampus) and prefrontal structures (e.g., right inferior frontal gyrus), and males activate a distributed network inclusive of more parietal regions. These data provide a framework for future investigations using functional or effective connectivity methods to elucidate the underpinnings of gender differences in neural network recruitment during working memory tasks.
Significance Explaining how structure of the brain gives rise to its emerging dynamics is a primary pursuit in neuroscience. We describe a fundamental anatomical constraint that emphasizes the key role of rare long-range (LR) connections in explaining functional organization of the brain in terms of spontaneous and task-evoked activity. Specifically, this constraint unifies brain geometry and local connectivity through the exponential distance rule while considering the LR exceptions to this local connectivity as derived from the structural connectome. In addition, when using this structural information, we show that the task-evoked brain activity is described by a low-dimensional manifold of several modes, suggesting that less is more for the efficient information processing in the brain.
Brain networks exhibit non-trivial modular organization, with groups of densely connected areas participating in specialized functions. Traditional community detection algorithms assign each node to one module, but this representation cannot capture integrative, multifunctional nodes that span multiple communities. Despite the increasing availability of overlapping community detection algorithms (OCDAs) to capture such integrative nodes, there is no objective procedure for selecting the most appropriate method and its parameters for a given problem. Here, we overcome this limitation by introducing a data-driven method for selecting an OCDA and its parameters from performance on a tailored ensemble of generated benchmark networks, assessing 22 unique algorithms and parameter settings. Applied to the human right-hemisphere structural connectome, we find that the "order statistics local optimization method" (OSLOM) best identifies ground-truth overlapping structure in the benchmark ensemble, yielding a seven-network decomposition of the right-hemisphere cortex. These modules are bridged by 15 overlapping regions that generally sit at the apex of the putative cortical hierarchy-suggesting integrative, higher order function-with network participation increasing along the cortical hierarchy, a finding not supported using a non-overlapping modular decomposition. This data-driven approach to selecting OCDAs is applicable across domains, opening new avenues to detecting and quantifying informative structures in complex real-world networks.
natural selection and sexual selection. Like other organs and tissues, this functional structure should be universally shared amongst humans and should have
Evolutionary psychology is a theoretical approach in psychology that examines cognition and behavior from a modern evolutionary perspective. It seeks to identify human psychological adaptations with regard to the ancestral problems they evolved to solve. In this framework, psychological traits and mechanisms are either functional products of natural and sexual selection or non-adaptive by-products
A…
Everything we examined (5)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.