Consuming water or tea is dangerous for young infants
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
Medical and nutritional literature indicates that giving supplemental fluids like water or tea to young infants is unnecessary and can adversely affect their health, leading to increased risks of illness and mortality.
Breast feeding in the first six months. Virtually all mothers in developing countries tend to supplement breast milk with water or teas, often during the infant's 1st week, thinking that these fluids have therapeutic effects. Moreover many physicians encourage this practice. It is unnecessary and could adversely affect infant health. Exclusively breast fed infants are less likely to suffer from diarrhea. For example, studies in the Philippines and Peru show that 6 month old breast fed infants who also received other fluids suffered from diarrhea at twice the rate of those who were exclusively breast fed. Further a study in Brazil reveals that these infants were more likely to die than those who only received breast milk. Moreover infants who received fluids other than breast milk consume less breast milk and breast feed for shorter duration than exclusively breast fed infants. In Brazil, breast fed infants who received supplements in the 1st days of life were 2 times as likely to not breast feed after 3 months than exclusively breast fed infants. Thus growth in infants who receive water or teas will not be optimal.
particularly dangerous for an infant, supplemental fluids (whether water or an infant electrolyte … or Fact?: Are Vegan Diets Appropriate for Young Children? 647 NUTRITION FOR CHILDREN, … than transparent foods such as mineral water or gelatin. b. Foods with a lot of nutrients
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.