Conservation laws can be derived directly from continuous symmetries without using the Lagrangian formalism via Noether's theorem extensions
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
4 sources for · 0 against
Peer-reviewed literature demonstrates that conservation laws and corresponding constants of motion can be derived from symmetries without relying on the Lagrangian formalism, using extended identities and non-Lagrangian approaches.
An identity is derived which yields a correspondence between symmetries and conservation laws for self-adjoint differential equations. This identity does not rely on use of a Lagrangian as needed to obtain conservation laws by Noether’s theorem. Moreover, unlike Noether’s theorem, which can only generate conservation laws from local symmetries, the derived identity generates conservation laws from nonlocal as well as local symmetries. It is explicitly shown how Noether’s theorem is extended by the identity. Conservation laws arising from nonlocal symmetries are obtained for a class of scalar wave equations with variable wave speeds. The constants of motion resulting from these nonlocal conservation laws are shown to be linearly independent of all constants of motion resulting from local conservation laws.
Abstract
We show that we can obtain expressions for conserved quantities directly from Newton’s second law. These conserved quantities coincide with the ones that are obtained with the aid of Noether’s theorem in the Lagrangian formalism. In particular, we consider the motion of a charged particle in an inhomogeneous electromagnetic field and we find constants of motion associated with the symmetries of the electromagnetic field, which are explicitly gauge-invariant. These constants of motion lead directly to conserved operators in the quantum formulation of the problem.
The Lie group method is a powerful technique for obtaining analytical solutions for various nonlinear differential equations. This study aimed to explore the behavior of nonlinear elastic wave equations and their underlying physical properties using Lie group invariants. We derived eight-dimensional symmetry algebra for the (3+1)-dimensional nonlinear elastic wave equation, which was used to obtain the optimal system. Group-invariant solutions were obtained using this optimal system. The same analysis was conducted for the damped version of this equation. For the conservation laws, we applied Noether's theorem to the nonlinear elastic wave equations owing to the availability of a classical Lagrangian. However, for the damped version, we cannot obtain a classical Lagrangian, which makes Noether's theorem inapplicable. Instead, we used an extended approach based on the concept of a partial Lagrangian to uncover conservation laws. Both techniques account for the conservation laws of linear momentum and energy within the model. These novel approaches add an application of variational calculus to the existing literature. This offers valuable insights and potential avenues for further exploration of the elastic wave equations.
A generalized Noether theorem is presented, relating symmetries and (equivalence classes of local) conservation laws in classical field theories; this is contrasted with the standard theorem. The concept of a “Noether” field theory is introduced, being a theory for which the generalized theorem applies; not only does this include the cases of Lagrangian and Hamiltonian field theories, these structures are “derived” from the Noether property in a natural way. The generalized theorem applies to currents and symmetries that contain derivatives of the fields up to an arbitrarily high order.
Everything we examined (4)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.