Certain reducing agents can selectively reduce aromatic ketones in the presence of nitro groups.
the verdict
CONTESTED
contested - the weight sits with the supporting side
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
The listed sources discuss the selective reduction of nitro compounds rather than the selective reduction of aromatic ketones in the presence of nitro groups, leading to a contested match with the claim.
The selective enzymatic reduction of nitroaliphatic and nitroaromatic compounds to aliphatic amines and amino-, azoxy- and azo-aromatics, respectively, remains a persisting challenge for biocatalysis. Here we demonstrate the light-powered, selective photoenzymatic synthesis of aliphatic amines and amino-, azoxy- and azo-aromatics from the corresponding nitro compounds. The nitroreductase from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens, in synergy with a photocatalytic system based on chlorophyll, promotes selective conversions of electronically-diverse nitroarenes into a series of aromatic amino, azoxy and azo products with excellent yield (up to 97%). The exploitation of an alternative nitroreductase from Enterobacter cloacae enables the tailoring of a photoenzymatic system for the challenging synthesis of aliphatic amines from nitroalkenes and nitroalkanes (up to 90% yield). This photoenzymatic reduction overcomes the competing bio-Nef reaction, typically hindering the complete enzymatic reduction of nitroaliphatics. The results highlight the usefulness of nitroreductases to create selective photoenzymatic systems for the synthesis of precious chemicals, and the effectiveness of chlorophyll as an innocuous photocatalyst, enabling the use of sunlight to drive the photobiocatalytic reactions.
2873 ncomms Nature Communications Nat Commun Nature Publishing Group PMC10482925 10482925 10482925 37673927 10.1038/s41467-023-41194-w Tailored photoenzymatic systems for selective reduction of aliphatic and aromatic nitro compounds fueled by light Luján Alejandro Prats 1 Bhat Mohammad Faizan 1 Tsaturyan Sona 1 van Merkerk Ronald 1 Fu Haigen 2 Poelarends Gerrit J 1 ✉ 1 Department of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Biology, Groningen Research Institute of Pharmacy, University of Groningen, Antonius Deusinglaan 1, 9713 AV Groningen, The Netherlands 2 Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14850 USA ✉ Corresponding author.
Flavoenzymes such as nitroreductases are able to reduce nitro compounds in aqueous conditions with a certain degree of chemo- and regio-selectivity. These enzymes catalyze the reduction of nitro (–NO 2 ) groups into amines (–NH 2 ) via nitroso (–NO) and hydroxylamine (–NHOH) intermediates by using prosthetic flavin and NAD(P)H cofactors 28 – 32 . However, the selective reduction of nitro compounds is a persisting challenge for biocatalysis, frequently resulting in a mixture of intermediates and incomplete reductions 30 , 33 , 34 .
Photoenzymatic synthesis of aromatic amines using BaNTR1 Next, we sought to explore the scope and limitations of this photoenzymatic reaction. Pleasingly, a wide variety of nitroarenes are well accepted by BaNTR1 (Fig. 2 , Suppl. Fig. 2 , and Suppl. Fig. 3 ). Nitroarenes possessing electron-withdrawing groups such as halogens, nitrile and trifluoromethyl at different positions are efficiently converted to
Nitroarene substrates containing electron-withdrawing and electron-donating groups at different positions are well accepted by BaNTR1, providing the desired aromatic azoxy products 37–51 with excellent conversions and selectivity (Fig. 3 and Suppl. Fig. 4 ). Remarkably, BaNTR1 is capable of chemoselectively reducing the nitro group over the carbonyl group ( 48–49 ). Moreover, the heterocyclic azoxy compound 52 can also be synthesized using this photoenzymatic system. However, starting substrates containing amine, hydroxy, and more complex structures resulted in a mixture of products without the formation of the corresponding azoxy product.
By screening an in-house panel of flavoenzymes 45 , we found that the nitroreductase EcNR, which also exhibits activity towards nitroaromatics, achieved the formation of minor amounts of the respective aliphatic amine product from both nitro compounds (Suppl. Table 5 ). During the optimization of the reaction conditions, we observed that the addition of the mild reducing agent, ascorbic acid, improved the conversion into amine to 25–37% (Suppl. Table 6 ). Alternatively, when the reaction was performed under photobiocatalytic conditions (chlorophyll and red LEDs), the amine synthesis also showed a remarkable increase in conversion (64–73%).
5 , Suppl. Fig. 6 ). Interestingly, EcNR can process nitroalkenes and nitroalkanes harboring a phenyl ring (or cyclohexene group), which can either be in conjugation with the nitro functionality or separated from the nitro group by a methylene bridge. For the panel of nitroalkenes, the EcNR-based photoenzymatic system performed the reduction of electronically diverse substrates, reducing the nitro group as well as the carbon-carbon double bond, achieving the synthesis of the corresponding aliphatic amines ( 68–77 , up to >99%).
On the other hand, the addition of a strong oxidant (H 2 O 2 ) promotes the photoenzymatic formation of nitroso and hydroxylamine intermediates, followed by their spontaneous condensation into azoxy products. Interestingly, the addition of a milder oxidant (molecular oxygen) to the photoenzymatic reaction leads toward the accumulation of azoxy products while allowing a further reduction into aromatic azo compounds. Finally, the selection of an alternative nitroreductase, EcNR, and the inclusion of a mild reducing agent, ascorbic acid, allows for the efficient photobiocatalytic synthesis of a series of aliphatic amines.
We recently reported that nitroreductase BaNTR1 can perform the reduction of ketones following a presumed ketyl radical formation under photoenzymatic conditions 45 . In addition, the reduction of nitroarenes via single electron transfers has been reported previously using light-mediated photochemical radical pathways 25 . The photoenzymatic systems reported herein represent an alternative to chemical and photochemical methods, overcoming the inability to selectively achieve multiple products from a single starting material and effectively producing highly valuable aliphatic amines from the corresponding nitro compounds.
Cleaner synthesis of amines remains a key challenge in organic chemistry because of their prevalence in pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals and synthetic building blocks. Here, we report a different paradigm for chemoselective hydrogenation of nitro compounds to amines, under mild, aqueous conditions. The hydrogenase enzyme releases electrons from H2 to a carbon black support which facilitates nitro-group reduction. For 30 nitroarenes we demonstrate full conversion (isolated yields 78 – 96%), with products including pharmaceuticals benzocaine, procainamide and mesalazine, and 4-aminophenol – precursor to paracetamol (acetaminophen). We also showcase gram-scale synthesis of procainamide with 90% isolated yield. We demonstrate potential for extension to aliphatic substrates. The catalyst is highly selective for reduction of the nitro group over other unsaturated bonds, tolerant to a wide range of functional groups, and exhibits excellent stability in reactions lasting up to 72 hours and full reusability over 5 cycles with a total turnover number over 1 million, indicating scope for direct translation to fine chemical manufacturing. The reduction of nitro-groups is a common synthetic route to amines, but biocatalytic strategies for such reactions are still being developed. In this study, the authors repurposed the hydrogenase enzyme by immobilisation on carbon black to yield a heterogeneous chemobiocatalyst for selective production of amines.
The hydrogenase enzyme releases electrons from H 2 to a carbon black support which facilitates nitro-group reduction. For 30 nitroarenes we demonstrate full conversion (isolated yields 78 – 96%), with products including pharmaceuticals benzocaine, procainamide and mesalazine, and 4-aminophenol – precursor to paracetamol (acetaminophen). We also showcase gram-scale synthesis of procainamide with 90% isolated yield. We demonstrate potential for extension to aliphatic substrates.
The catalyst is highly selective for reduction of the nitro group over other unsaturated bonds, tolerant to a wide range of functional groups, and exhibits excellent stability in reactions lasting up to 72 hours and full reusability over 5 cycles with a total turnover number over 1 million, indicating scope for direct translation to fine chemical manufacturing. Subject terms: Biocatalysis, Heterogeneous catalysis The reduction of nitro-groups is a common synthetic route to amines, but biocatalytic strategies for such reactions are still being developed.
This has led to a wide range of developments in selective methods for amine synthesis 1 – 3 , including various biocatalytic approaches 4 – 8 . The reduction of nitro-groups is a common synthetic route to amines, and is a key target for greener synthetic protocols because the available routes are dominated by use of stoichiometric reductants or precious-metal hydrogenations which often lack functional group selectivity (Fig. 1B ) 9 – 12 .
It is known that organonitro groups can be electrochemically reduced to the amine at a carbon electrode surface in aqueous electrolyte, suggesting the possibility of harnessing an ‘electrochemical hydrogenation’ mechanism in reduction of nitro compounds 21 . In fact, it has been noted recently that nitro group hydrogenations at palladium on carbon (Pd/C) may actually proceed via an electrochemical mechanism whereby H 2 oxidation occurs at active sites on the Pd and provides electrons for reduction of the nitro compound at the carbon support 22 .
We therefore hypothesised that a catalyst comprising Hyd-1 immobilised on carbon black particles (Hyd-1/C) should be able to carry out the hydrogenation of nitrobenzene, where the reduction of the nitro group would occur at the carbon surface, akin to an electrochemical half reaction, using electrons supplied from H 2 oxidation by the hydrogenase as shown in Fig. 1C . Fig. 2 Onset potential for nitrobenzene reduction and H 2 oxidation on a carbon electrode at 25 °C, pH 6.0.
Hyd-1 was immobilised by direct adsorption onto carbon black which we have previously shown is suitable for direct electron-exchange with Hyd-1 30 , 31 . After 12 hours of reaction under H 2 flow, we observed full conversion of 10 mM nitrobenzene to aniline ( 1a ) with no side products. Control experiments confirm that neither Hyd-1 nor carbon particles alone show this reactivity (Supplementary Fig. 3 ). These results encouraged us to explore a wide range of aromatic nitro compounds to understand the substrate scope, functional group tolerance, and chemoselectivity of the Hyd-1/C catalyst, as summarised in Fig. 3 . All nitrobenzene derivatives shown in Fig.
Selectivity of Hyd-1/C for hydrogenation of the nitro group was demonstrated with substrates 18, 21, 26 - 28 for which full conversion of the nitro group to the amine was observed, with no evidence for reduction of ketone, aldehyde, alkene, alkyne or nitrile groups (Supplementary Figs. 23 , 26 , 31 – 33 ). Substrate 28 required higher catalyst loading and pH 8.0 to suppress the side reaction of alkyne hydration. The selectivity is consistent with the clean linear sweep voltammograms observed for electrochemical reduction of these nitroarenes at carbon.
Exploration of the mechanism and catalyst recycling To understand aspects of the mechanism of nitro hydrogenation we undertook further experiments with 1 as a model substrate. Figure 4B presents 1 H-NMR traces of the
Inspired by the concept of electrochemical hydrogenation in heterogeneous catalysis, we have established a hybrid bio-chemo catalyst, which operates entirely via an electrochemical (coupled redox) mechanism. We show that this gives an easy-to-use, highly versatile catalyst for the synthesis of amines via hydrogenation of aromatic nitro compounds under mild conditions. The catalyst comprises a carbon black supported NiFe hydrogenase (Hyd-1) which enables use of H 2 at atmospheric pressure as an atom-efficient reductant, without need for a co-catalyst or cofactor.
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.