Beta-galactosidase and luciferase reporter genes have distinct sensitivities and detection limits
the verdict
CONTESTED
contested - the weight sits with the supporting side
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
8 sources for · 0 against
The provided sources discuss various uses of luciferase and beta-galactosidase reporter assays in different contexts, but do not directly compare their specific sensitivities or detection limits.
Luciferases are enzymes that emit light in the presence of oxygen and a substrate (luciferin) and which have been used for real-time, low-light imaging of gene expression in cell cultures, individual cells, whole organisms, and transgenic organisms. Such luciferin-luciferase systems include, among others, the bacterial lux genes of terrestrial Photorhabdus luminescens and marine Vibrio harveyi bacteria, as well as eukaryotic luciferase luc and ruc genes from firefly species (Photinus) and the sea pansy (Renilla reniformis), respectively. In various vectors and in fusion constructs with other gene products such as green fluorescence protein (GFP; from the jellyfish Aequorea), luciferases have served as reporters in a number of promoter search and targeted gene expression experiments over the last two decades. Luciferase imaging has also been used to trace bacterial and viral infection in vivo and to visualize the proliferation of tumour cells in animal models.
This chapter summarizes four powerful assays for analyzing gene expression in cis-regulatory studies. The enzymatic assays (CAT, luciferase, lacZ) are currently limited by their application to embryo homogenates or fixed samples, but offer more robust analysis of gene activity than GFP. Assays based on CAT enzymatic activity or on CAT mRNA detection by WMISH are laborious but are well established for accurately quantifying gene expression and to determine spatial patterns at defined timepoints during development. LacZ assays are the current standard for spatially visualizing gene products in whole-mount fixed embryos. They are very sensitive but they provide limited temporal or quantitative information due to the perdurance of beta-galactosidase and the subtleties of the staining technique. Recently developed luciferase assays promise to be even more sensitive and accurate than the CAT and lacZ assays, and applicable to living cells and embryos. But, they have not yet been well established in invertebrate deuterostome research. GFP allows visualization of gene expression within living embryos. But because this is not an enzymatic assay, sensitivity can be a problem, particularly for weak promoters. Furthermore, imaging live embryos and quantifying gene expression in space and time (due to scattering of light by tissue, the perdurance of GFP, and other experimental details) is currently fraught with challenges. Ongoing improvements in imaging technology and the advent of multiple fluorescent proteins, as well as fluorescent and luminescent assays for vital imaging, will dramatically facilitate studies of gene expression in the coming decade.
Expression and quantification of firefly luciferase under control of Rhizobium meliloti symbiotic promoters.
We have tested the use of firefly luciferase for monitoring regulated symbiotic nitrogen fixation gene expression. Broad-host-range plasmids carrying translational fusions of Rhizobium meliloti nifH, fixA and nifA promoters were constructed. Despite low levels of promoter activity the absence of Escherichia coli endogenous luminescence and the high sensitivity of the bioluminescent assay for firefly luciferase allowed rapid screening for functional luciferase expression. Plasmids containing symbiotic promoter-luc fusions were established in R. meliloti. Luciferase activity was detected and measured in both vegetative and symbiotic cells giving comparable results with those obtained by beta-galactosidase assays. In addition, the luciferase assay was quicker, more sensitive and could be carried out with unrestricted cells. Furthermore, bioluminescence was high enough in alfalfa nodules containing nifH-luc fusion to be observed by a dark-adapted eye and photographed.
Published in Journal of bioluminescence and chemiluminescence
Bacterial luciferase produced with rapid-screening baculovirus vectors is a sensitive reporter for infection of insect cells and larvae. Bacterial luciferase, derived from a fusion of the luxA and luxB genes of Vibrio harveyi, has been expressed at very high levels in caterpillars and insect cells. The coding sequence for luciferase was inserted into vectors developed in our laboratory which were designed to expedite screening of recombinant virus. These vectors contained the beta-galactosidase indicator gene under control of immediate early (IE1), early (ETL), or very late (P10) promoters and a cloning site for inserting the fused luciferase gene next to the polyhedrin promoter. Recombinant baculoviruses containing the luciferase gene as well as the beta-galactosidase gene could be easily selected when Bluo-gal (beta-galactosidase indicator) was included in the plaque assays. Using cells derived from the fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda), luciferase was strongly expressed very late in infection (48-72 h). The bacterial luciferase assay was sufficiently sensitive that light production could be detected from an extract of a single cell.
Firefly luciferase luminescence assays using scintillation counters for quantitation in transfected mammalian cells.
The firefly enzyme luciferase catalyzes the luminescent reaction of luciferin with ATP and oxygen. The luciferase gene has recently been cloned and proposed as a reporter gene in procaryotic and eucaryotic cells. We present here a luciferase activity assay which relies on luminescence detection using a standard scintillation counter. This technique is simple, fast, inexpensive, and still very sensitive: as little as 0.02 pg (250,000 molecules) of enzyme is readily detected. The technique is optimized for the luciferase assay in mammalian cell lysates. Thus, the luciferase gene may become a very useful tool for gene regulation studies.
Published in Analytical biochemistry (1988)
A simple and sensitive in vivo luciferase assay for tRNA-mediated nonsense suppression. We present a rapid assay for tRNA suppression in living Escherichia coli. An amber, ochre, or opal nonsense mutation in a cloned luxB gene from the bacterium Vibrio harveyi was suppressed. Because luciferase (Lux) activity depends completely on the appearance of the full-length luxB gene product, the amount of light produced was proportional to tRNA-mediated nonsense suppression in the cell. This luminometric assay was notably quicker, easier, and more sensitive than a traditional colorimetric assay employing beta-galactosidase. Assays required only one addition to a growing culture and were complete within 1 min. Light output was directly proportional to the amount of bacterial luciferase in a sample over a range of greater than or equal to 40,000-fold. Fewer than 100 cells were required for detection of Lux with ordinary instrumentation; assays were 80-fold more sensitive than simultaneous beta-galactosidase measurements. Assayed cells survived and could be recovered as colony formers. The beta-galactosidase colorimetric assay and the luciferase assay were similarly reproducible.
Loligomers are peptide-based intracellular vehicles able to penetrate cells and self-localize into distinct cellular compartments. Loligomers can be rapidly assembled by automated solid-phase approaches and were designed to act as nonviral, nonlipophilic intracellular shuttles. One nucleus-directed loligomer, termed loligomer 4, was evaluated for its ability to function as a transfection agent. Loligomer 4 readily associates with plasmids to form noncovalent complexes. The migration of loligomer 4-plasmid complexes into cells was monitored by flow cytometry and fluorescence microscopy. Populations of plasmids labeled with 7-AAD exist either free or in association with loligomer 4 inside cells and are visible throughout the cytosol and nucleus of chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Loligomer 4-plasmid complexes were not cytotoxic to cells and were readily imported by most cells (>70%). CHO cells were transfected with complexes of loligomer 4 and plasmids harboring luciferase, green fluorescent protein or beta-galactosidase reporter genes. The transfection efficiency of loligomer 4-plasmid DNA complexes was greater when cells were maintained as suspensions instead of monolayers. Transfections could be performed with cells suspended in serum-containing medium. The observed levels of transfection, however, were modest with 5-10% of CHO cells expressing either a green fluorescent protein or the enzyme beta-galactosidase. Loligomers have recently been observed in vesicular compartme
When a transient or stable transfection assay is developed for a promoter, a primary objective is to quantify promoter strength. Because transfection efficiency in such assays can be low, promoters are commonly fused to heterologous reporter genes that encode enzymes that can be quantified using highly sensitive assays. The reporter protein's activity or fluorescence within a transfected cell population is approximately proportional to the steady-state mRNA level. Although the Escherichia coli lacZ gene, encoding beta-galactosidase (beta-gal), can be used as a standard reporter for monitoring the strength of a promoter or enhancer in a transient or stable transfection assay, it is predominantly used as an internal control during transient transfection experiments. When used in this manner, cells are usually transfected with the control plasmid (containing a ubiquitously active viral promoter fused to the E. coli lacZ gene) and an experimental plasmid containing another reporter gene (e.g., luciferase or chloramphenicol acetyltransferase [CAT]) under the control of the promoter or enhancer of interest. The basic colorimetric assay described here is the simplest and least expensive assay for quantifying beta-gal activity. The cells are lysed and, after determining the total protein concentration in the extracts, an aliquot of the extract is mixed with the reaction substrate, O-nitrophenyl-beta-D-galactopyranoside (ONPG), in a buffer containing sodium phosphate and magnesium chloride. When the yellow product becomes visible, the optical densities of the samples are determined spectrophotometrically.
Everything we examined (8)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.