A photograph of the Moon allows calculation of the photographer's terrestrial position using lunar librations and parallax
the verdict
INSUFFICIENT LEANING
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
2 sources for · 0 against
Retrieved records acknowledge the underlying concepts of lunar parallax and diurnal libration altering apparent features from different locations, but do not provide a fully settled calculation method establishing the claim.
n and position of the Moon as viewed from Tokyo, Japan and from Houston, Texas at the same moment. The first image pair is a close-up of the full Moon showing that observers in the two locations see a slightly different set of features at the eastern and western edges of the Moon. The second pair of images is a wider field of view showing how much the Moon's position is shifted against the background stars when seen from the two locations. A single observer can see these same parallax effects by viewing the Moon at different times during the night. Between moonrise and moonset, the Earth's rotation carries the observer from one side of the globe to the other. The resulting change in the apparent orientation of the Moon during the night is called diurnal libration . The Moon's position against the background stars also changes, but this is the combined effect of parallax and the Moon's motion in its orbit, which partially cancel each other out: In 12 hours, parallax can move the Moon's apparent position 2° to the west while its orbital motion moves it 6° to the east. Lunar parallax was used for over 2000 years to measure the distance to the Moon. Although the specific techniques vary, the essence of the method is the solution of the triangle formed by the Moon and two widely separated observers. By the early 1960s, this approach had produced a distance accurate to within a mile. It's now measured with lasers to within a fraction of an inch.
Download
Images
diurnal2.gif (1024x1024) [69.1 KB]
A two-frame animated GIF comparing the views of the full Moon from Tokyo and from Houston at the same instant. In these wider views, the position of the Moon among the background stars is significantly different when viewed from the two locations.
Planets & Moons
Lunar Surface
Lunar Topography
Moon
Credits
Please give credit for this item to: NASA's Scientific Visualization Studio
Visualizer
Ernie Wright
(USRA)
Technical support
Laurence Schuler
(ADNET Systems, Inc.)
Ian Jones
(AD
# Given a photo of the Moon, taken from Earth, is it possible to calculate the position of the photographer's site?
Tags: astronomy, astrometrics
- Score: 21
- Views: 2343
- Answers: 6
- Answered: yes
- Asked by: Alessandro Jacopson (759 rep)
- Asked: 2011-06-30
- Edited: 2012-05-10
- Site: physics
## Question
Given a photo of the Moon, taken from Earth, is it possible to calculate the position (Earth longitude and latitude) of the photographer's site?
I am thinking about photos taken with a normal camera lens and not with a telescope, for example photos taken with a 300 mm lens like these one:
http://www.flickr.com/search/?q=100+300+moon&l=cc&ct=0&mt=all&adv=1
I assume the photo shows enough detailed features like recognizable craters and maria.
Is there any software capable of solving the problem?
Thank you.
Alessandro
Addendum:
A diagram of a simplified model of the problem:
R is the radius of the Earth.
D is the (average) distance from the center of the Moon to the center of the Earth.
P is the photographer site on the surface of the Earth.
## Answers
### Answer by dagorym (score: 16 [ACCEPTED])
In theory, I think that it might be possible to get a rough estimat
Everything we examined (2)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.