16S rRNA sequencing has significant technical limitations
the verdict
SUPPORTED
the evidence backs this
refutedsupported
the weight of evidence
6 sources for · 0 against
Six peer-reviewed and reference sources discuss Next-generation sequencing approaches, taxonomic databases, and methodological analyses related to 16S rRNA sequencing.
AbstractOur growing awareness of the microbial world’s importance and diversity contrasts starkly with our limited understanding of its fundamental structure. Despite recent advances in DNA sequencing, a lack of standardized protocols and common analytical frameworks impedes comparisons among studies, hindering the development of global inferences about microbial life on Earth. Here we present a meta-analysis of microbial community samples collected by hundreds of researchers for the Earth Microbiome Project. Coordinated protocols and new analytical methods, particularly the use of exact sequences instead of clustered operational taxonomic units, enable bacterial and archaeal ribosomal RNA gene sequences to be followed across multiple studies and allow us to explore patterns of diversity at an unprecedented scale. The result is both a reference database giving global context to DNA sequence data and a framework for incorporating data from future studies, fostering increasingly complete characterization of Earth’s microbial diversity.
ABSTRACT The long-read amplicon provides a species-level solution for the community. With the improvement of nanopore flowcells, the accuracy of Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) R10.4.1 has been substantially enhanced, with an average of approximately 99%. To evaluate its effectiveness on amplicons, three types of microbiomes were analyzed by 16S ribosomal RNA (hereinafter referred to as “16S”) amplicon sequencing using Novaseq, Pacbio sequel II, and Nanopore PromethION platforms (R9.4.1 and R10.4.1) in the current study. We showed the error rate, recall, precision, and bias index in the mock sample. The error rate of ONT R10.4.1 was greatly reduced, with a better recall in the case of the synthetic community. Meanwhile, in different types of environmental samples, ONT R10.4.1 analysis resulted in a composition similar to Pacbio data. We found that classification tools and databases influence ONT data. Based on these results, we conclude that the ONT R10.4.1 16S amplicon can also be used for application in environmental samples. IMPORTANCE The long-read amplicon supplies the community with a species-level solution. Due to the high error rate of nanopore sequencing early on, it has not been frequently used in 16S studies. Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) introduced the R10.4.1 flowcell with Q20+ reagent to achieve more than 99% accuracy as sequencing technology advanced. However, there has been no published study on the performance of commercial PromethION sequencers with R10.4.1 flowcells on 16S sequencing or on the impact of accuracy improvement on taxonomy (R9.4.1 to R10.4.1) using 16S ONT data. In this study, three types of microbiomes were investigated by 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) amplicon sequencing using Novaseq, Pacbio sequel II, and Nanopore PromethION platforms (R9.4.1 and R10.4.1). In the mock sample, we displayed the error rate, recall, precision, and bias index. We observed that the error rate in ONT R10.4.1 is significantly lower, especially when deletions are involved. First and foremost, R10.4.1 and Pacific Bioscience platforms reveal a similar microbiome in environmental samples. This study shows that the R10.4.1 full-length 16S rRNA sequences allow for species identification of environmental microbiota. The long-read amplicon supplies the community with a species-level solution. Due to the high error rate of nanopore sequencing early on, it has not been frequently used in 16S studies. Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) introduced the R10.4.1 flowcell with Q20+ reagent to achieve more than 99% accuracy as sequencing technology advanced. However, there has been no published study on the performance of commercial PromethION sequencers with R10.4.1 flowcells on 16S sequencing or on the impact of accuracy improvement on taxonomy (R9.4.1 to R10.4.1) using 16S ONT data. In this study, three types of microbiomes were investigated by 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) amplicon sequencing using Novaseq, Pacbio sequel II, and Nanopore PromethION platforms (R9.4.1 and R10.4.1). In the mock sample, we displayed the error rate, recall, precision, and bias index. We observed that the error rate in ONT R10.4.1 is significantly lower, especially when deletions are involved. First and foremost, R10.4.1 and Pacific Bioscience platforms reveal a similar microbiome in environmental samples. This study shows that the R10.4.1 full-length 16S rRNA sequences allow for species identification of environmental microbiota.
ABSTRACT Amplicon-based 16S ribosomal RNA sequencing remains a widely used method to profile microbial communities, especially in low biomass samples, due to its cost-effectiveness and low-complexity approach. Reference databases are a mainstay for taxonomic assignments, which typically rely on popular databases such as SILVA, Greengenes, Genome Taxonomy Database (GTDB), or Ribosomal Database Project (RDP). However, the inconsistency of the nomenclature across databases and the presence of shortcomings in the annotation of these databases are limiting the resolution of the analysis. To overcome these limitations, we created the GSR database (Greengenes, SILVA, and RDP database), an integrated and manually curated database for bacterial and archaeal 16S amplicon taxonomy analysis. Unlike previous integration approaches, this database creation pipeline includes a taxonomy unification step to ensure consistency in taxonomical annotations. The database was validated with three mock communities, two real data sets, and a 10-fold cross-validation method and compared with existing 16S databases such as Greengenes, Greengenes 2, GTDB, ITGDB, SILVA, RDP, and MetaSquare. Results showed that the GSR database enhances taxonomical annotations of 16S sequences, outperforming current 16S databases at the species level, based on the evaluation of the mock communities. This was confirmed by the 10-fold cross-validation, except for Greengenes 2. The GSR database is available for full-length 16S sequences and the most commonly used hypervariable regions: V4, V1–V3, V3–V4, and V3–V5. IMPORTANCE Taxonomic assignments of microorganisms have long been hindered by inconsistent nomenclature and annotation issues in existing databases like SILVA, Greengenes, Greengenes2, Genome Taxonomy Database, or Ribosomal Database Project. To overcome these issues, we created Greengenes-SILVA-RDP database (GSR-DB), accurate and comprehensive taxonomic annotations of 16S amplicon data. Unlike previous approaches, our innovative pipeline includes a unique taxonomy unification step, ensuring consistent and reliable annotations. Our evaluation analyses showed that GSR-DB outperforms existing databases in providing species-level resolution, especially based on mock-community analysis, making it a game-changer for microbiome studies. Moreover, GSR-DB is designed to be accessible to researchers with limited computational resources, making it a powerful tool for scientists across the board. Available for full-length 16S sequences and commonly used hypervariable regions, including V4, V1–V3, V3–V4, and V3–V5, GSR-DB is a go-to database for robust and accurate microbial taxonomy analysis. Taxonomic assignments of microorganisms have long been hindered by inconsistent nomenclature and annotation issues in existing databases like SILVA, Greengenes, Greengenes2, Genome Taxonomy Database, or Ribosomal Database Project. To overcome these issues, we created Greengenes-SILVA-RDP database (GSR-DB), accurate and comprehensive taxonomic annotations of 16S amplicon data. Unlike previous approaches, our innovative pipeline includes a unique taxonomy unification step, ensuring consistent and reliable annotations. Our evaluation analyses showed that GSR-DB outperforms existing databases in providing species-level resolution, especially based on mock-community analysis, making it a game-changer for microbiome studies. Moreover, GSR-DB is designed to be accessible to researchers with limited computational resources, making it a powerful tool for scientists across the board. Available for full-length 16S sequences and commonly used hypervariable regions, including V4, V1–V3, V3–V4, and V3–V5, GSR-DB is a go-to database for robust and accurate microbial taxonomy analysis.
DNA sequencing technologies play a key role in modern soil microbiome research, providing a deep understanding of its structure and functional role in ecosystems. 16S rRNA gene, region of 18S-ITS-28S sequencing and shotgun sequencing using modern sequencing technologies (Illumina, Pacific Biosciences (PacBio), Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT)) allow us to identify the diversity and dynamics of microbial communities with high accuracy and resolution, which significantly expands our knowledge of biological processes and interactions between microorganisms in the soil. Soil microbiome analysis using sequencing contributes to the development of innovative methods for sustainable agricultural land management, improved fertility, plant disease management, and increased crop yields. Despite its significant potential, each sequencing technology has its own advantages and limitations related to accuracy, depth of coverage, cost, and data analysis complexity. Understanding these characteristics is crucial for selecting the optimal methods depending on the research objectives and available resources. This review systematizes modern sequencing methods, their technical capabilities and limitations, bioinformatics tools for sequencing data analysis, considers examples of successful applications in the study of soil microbiome in various ecosystems, and emphasizes new trends in metagenomics. In-depth study and development of soil microbiome sequencing technologies contributes to more sust
Rapid determination of 16S ribosomal RNA sequences for phylogenetic analyses. Although the applicability of small subunit ribosomal RNA (16S rRNA) sequences for bacterial classification is now well accepted, the general use of these molecules has been hindered by the technical difficulty of obtaining their sequences. A protocol is described for rapidly generating large blocks of 16S rRNA sequence data without isolation of the 16S rRNA or cloning of its gene. The 16S rRNA in bulk cellular RNA preparations is selectively targeted for dideoxynucleotide-terminated sequencing by using reverse transcriptase and synthetic oligodeoxynucleotide primers complementary to universally conserved 16S rRNA sequences. Three particularly useful priming sites, which provide access to the three major 16S rRNA structural domains, routinely yield 800-1000 nucleotides of 16S rRNA sequence. The method is evaluated with respect to accuracy, sensitivity to modified nucleotides in the template RNA, and phylogenetic usefulness, by examination of several 16S rRNAs whose gene sequences are known.
Abstract Healthcare-associated infections (HAIs) impose substantial clinical and economic burdens globally, affecting approximately 7% of hospitalized patients in developed countries and causing over 99,000 deaths annually in the United States alone. This narrative review critically evaluates molecular techniques for detecting and identifying nosocomial pathogens, emphasizing their integration into infection surveillance and control strategies. Key bacterial agents examined include spore-forming organisms like Clostridioides difficile, Gram-positive pathogens such as Staphylococcus aureus and Enterococcus species, and Gram-negative bacteria including Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Klebsiella pneumoniae, and Acinetobacter baumannii. Advanced diagnostic modalities assessed include polymerase chain reaction (PCR), 16S rRNA gene sequencing, whole-genome sequencing (WGS), matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS), metagenomics, and emerging CRISPR-Cas-based diagnostics. Environmental sampling challenges, biofilm-associated resistance mechanisms, and high-touch surface contamination are analyzed. Integration of molecular diagnostics into routine surveillance has demonstrated significant improvements in outbreak detection (reducing identification time by 48-72 hours), transmission tracking accuracy (>40% improvement in epidemiological investigations), and targeted intervention implementation. Current limitations include cost barriers, techn
Everything we examined (6)
This check searched the claim as stated. It did not run a separate search for evidence against it.